Sisterwolf
on hah by xanthippe
28 Dec 2005, 12:15 PM
I have no legs because I am a superb example of
frog-ness, and my legs really are my best feature.
I wish I had something constructive to offer -
but shock value poetry doesn't do it for me.
No barbed comment back, please, I really care.
I offer critiques in all sincerity, so, I think you
could rework this a bit - 3rd line: shortening it or
The trick is in darting
between the teeth. . . as a suggestion.
Tapping them on the tongue is great
There are a lot of good basics here, but it yaws
in order to make certain statements.
Line two of verse 2 should be 'has opened' - don't sacrifice good grammer to achieve an end.
Some deep emotions here. Line 7 should say 'ground' instead of grown. The odd spacing tears up your cohesiveness. When you have good stuff to say, it
doesn't need a lot of odd punctuation . . .
A rewrite would be my suggestion. I would love to
read it if you do one.
Just a first thought I had... numbering detracts from
the power of your words. Need a capital S in first line. Repetitive she lends it a rhythm.
In my opinion, using thine and thys is risky. Those are usually used in reference to a deity. None of the tone of the rest of your work uses formal English to match. Hateness is not a word. There is an incongruity with soldiers out of breath...smacks of reaching for a rhyme. Next to last line -thine is not proper - thy is
correct. Last line, there is no need for an apostrophe with see's... the apostrophe makes a
possessive. Same on fourth line from bottom - no apostrophe.
I know poetry used to have all first line capitals, but
I feel it lends to the flow if second lines are in
small case.
Intranet, may I point out that I got scolded for having made no useful criticism - ie, great work, etal.
This poem has no constructive criticism at all.
No big deal, but I thought about what you said and
have been critiquing to help because I thought praise
was not acceptable comment. Peace!
Cute observation.
I like the end it wraps it up well
Good good good good good. Anvil eyed. Daimler. Could you make it longer? Seems shor for memoirs. 9.5
Second verse, lines 2 and 3 don't make a clear
statement, at least to me. Good basics here - needs spit and polish.
Your absolutes rock. This would be better as an essay, in my opinion. Needs a cleanup of punctuation and spelling, and you need a space between until and when.
I think you have a good piece to trim and mold into
a really nice essay.
Lots of love here. I think it would do well with
some pruning and tightening up, endline repair,
and pruning. It is jagged to read, needs a smoother flow to do justice to your thoughts.
Such angst. This really needs tightening and endline
cohesion of some kind - as is it rambles all over the page. Take it from me, add punctuation, it gives
edges and smoothes out the bumps.
Cute. Maybe a stretch for rhyme though, my friend.
line 6 is out of synch... could omit 'trapped and'.
Cheese wigs is not a familiar term to me, so am supposing it is a bug??
I'll echo the six. Read this aloud to yourself and you'll be able to fix it easily.