poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 4101–4120 back. Include replies to comments

Edna Sweetlove on some deleted poem 27 Oct 2006, 4:27 PM
Very amusing. I loved the negroid bit.
Edna Sweetlove on Brackish by <~> 29 Oct 2006, 5:05 PM
Deeply boring and pretentious. Over-punctuated and empty.
ALChemy on The Pit’s Bottom by Dovina 29 Oct 2006, 6:38 AM
The Tao of Dovina.
Dovina on Blue, Black & White by oneglove 27 Oct 2006, 2:31 PM
Reads like a song. Call it a lyric and give it a tune.
Utterly terrible. Total defecation. 10/10 for a good laugh!
Stephen Robins on Your Eyes by Dovina 29 Oct 2006, 10:22 AM
How do you do it?
Ranger on some deleted poem 27 Oct 2006, 4:34 AM
Tenning this out of sheer principle. Also because the first stanza is utter genius.
Edna Sweetlove on Fascists by Imago 29 Oct 2006, 4:40 AM
Trite. You probably don't even know what a fascist is. I shall be generous for a change: 1/10
A bit of punctuation would have done no harm. But it's OK I suppose. Noy exactly profound that last line, is it?
Edna Sweetlove on The Pit’s Bottom by Dovina 27 Oct 2006, 4:31 PM
A combination of pretentiousness and ignorance. Boring too! I'll be generous and score it 4/10, no silly me 2/10.
Actually it's England that's on the wrong side of the street. We had cars first. Anything to prove your not our 51st state.
Edna Sweetlove on The world's shortest poem by ALChemy 29 Oct 2006, 4:32 AM
Not short enough. It is wonderful to find someone who writes a two word poem AND ONE OF THEM IS SPELLED WRONGLY! An unbeatable achievment.
Edna Sweetlove on Vote Goats by ALChemy 29 Oct 2006, 4:34 AM
Well, this poem is very badly written. It also contains poor grammar and syntax. And the primordial slime bit is a bit over the top. I am tempted to give it 0/10 just out of bitchiness but that would be unfair as it holds a kernel of truth in its clumsiness. So 5/10. You can't say fairer than that now can you, Al, dearie?
Embarrassingly badly written. The first stanza is doggerel. The use of "man" in the last line is appalling. I think you have found your true vocation in the armed forces. A gun will lie better in your hands than a pen. Happy shooting and killing!
Edna Sweetlove on some deleted poem 29 Oct 2006, 4:30 AM
It's not that you are illiterate (a common failing among Americans, and one I am delighted to see you do not share) but that you are a very poor writer. "An ambulance was a mother’s womb The gunshot victim, in utero, waited to be birthed" Surely you can see that is pretentious twaddle? Why not write and condemn a country which allows unrestricted access to guns?
Edna Sweetlove on Jesus in a leisure suit by Imago 29 Oct 2006, 4:43 AM
This shows promise especially the references to the horrible car you drive. What a pity it is wrecked by these hideous lines... "to where I wanna be But my mind is floating off the berm" Why use a non-word like "wanna"? And what does a raised river bank have to do with it?
Edna Sweetlove on The Perigenetic Prayer by ALChemy 29 Oct 2006, 5:01 PM
More illiterate crud.
drnick on some deleted poem 27 Oct 2006, 8:40 AM
Why don't more people think like this?
drnick on The Pit’s Bottom by Dovina 27 Oct 2006, 8:52 AM
I'm not sure I deserved a response such as this, but thank you. This is very good, however im not completely sure of the over-all message you're trying to convey here. And evil is not a mystery, evil is me. I am evil, I am the DEVIL (woogy-boogy).
Dovina on Consider this by MacFrantic 27 Oct 2006, 2:26 PM
Don’t “think twice about God or the Devil. We are fragments in a sea of ineffable words.” I feel that way often. Sometimes I think it’s impossible to talk about God or the Devil without resorting to analogy or metaphor. Some say that if anthropomorphic language is all we have in these matters it becomes added evidence for their non-existence. I disagree but see their point. Some good thoughts here, but could be more poetic, and at least called “prose poem.”