poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 22001–22020 back. Include replies to comments

edpeterson on Diary by wilco 12 Apr 2004, 6:53 AM
i think it is pretty damn good. simple. ONly just shy of elegant.
Shuushin on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 7:47 AM
keep the title as is.
Tara57 on Rough draft of a poetry manifesto by zodiac 12 Apr 2004, 8:14 AM
The title I like...not blown away by the poem
Shuushin on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 8:15 AM
Hey Ed. This one would *greatly* benefit from far less little words (my broken record peeve). You're painting little pictures here, I don't need to read all these prepositional phrases to see the same thing - they distract the reader. One example, okay - I love this concept of yours: "On the television appear the letters M U T E Television, green letters M U T E you could even toss a descriptor onto television if you wanted. I sincerely believe your poetry, especially this type of poem, will improve significantly if you let go of this desire to fill in all the blanks with little words. You've probably heard this basic rule a hundred times - show, don't tell - these little words are part of the telling; danger danger.
edpeterson on Everyone's choosing sides by zodiac 12 Apr 2004, 8:16 AM
Excellent piece.
some deleted user on short clip about dc, #2 by jsd 12 Apr 2004, 8:28 AM
Succinct! The last line, though, "wearing" seems wrong, maybe something stronger like shouting.
some deleted user on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 8:35 AM
A good song, but it tells the listener a little too much. It's better to imagine some things.
some deleted user on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 8:38 AM
Some ofthe lines seem too long and some of the phrases seem wordy. Otherwise a good poem.
zodiac on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 8:42 AM
Don't be thrown off by my giving you a seven. This is several steps better than your other recent stuff. Some of these lines are kind of stale, but I'm impressed with how you've fit them together and given them a kind of order and drive, rather than stringing together only semi-related phrases like we see so much of here. I really feel like this leads somewhere, which is great. Now I would strongly recommend trying out other subjects. It's not that I don't consider love and heartbreak important (I do!-wait till you see my post tonight!), but that so many things have been said about love and heartbreak; it's hard to find something new to say about it. Whereas, say, writing about being an alien drain-cleaner on an interstellar battle-cruiser is totally new; you'd couldn't be cliche with a topic like that. Anyway, I didn't want you to think I was some terrible bogey or grouchy invalid or anything such. See? I can be a nice guy, even! Good luck writing, and tchuss! -zodiac
funny, but i have not been here long enough to know what the fuck you are talking about. go down on your bad self.
Caducus on EGG by ?-Dave_Mysterious-? 12 Apr 2004, 11:41 AM
True to the title
Caducus on AIDS in a van by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 12 Apr 2004, 11:42 AM
real moving man.
ggawrysi on This guy by Jai 12 Apr 2004, 12:01 PM
a rather boring poem with a generic point... not to mention that it's "you're," not "your." there's nothing wrong with a short, cute poem; just give it more distinction and more impact.
ggawrysi on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 12:06 PM
i just typed out this really long and in depth comment, hit "submit," and the computer lost it. so now you get the abridged version. the first stanza sticks out; it points in a direction that the poem does not take. other than that, i have only pithy criticisms regarding grammar, structure, etc., criticisms that don't really matter towards the meaning of the poem. it has a distinct and personal point, and ZODIAC is incorrect; it is not about lost love and broken hearts but intrinsically connected friends. well done.
nentwined on moment in time by calilegzzz 12 Apr 2004, 12:26 PM
"cool crips breeze" had me thinking this was an entirely different poem for the first three lines (well, there was uncertainty after the first line ended, and serious doubt after the second...) "nights" should be "night's". "raceing" is "racing" I don't understand "which arouses yet another thought you..."--is that supposed to be another thought _of_ you? 'moment in time' is one of my favorite phrases, but it doesn't seem like you really did anything with it here but tack it on at the end, almost like this was an assignment to "write about a moment in time". I'm afraid that this poem reads to me as one cliche after another--pretty words, but the same words everyone else has used to describe the exact same thing. I think you could explore the moment and metaphors a bit more to try to find something novel.
ggawrysi on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 12:38 PM
a little explanation on "a sense of order urges/a need for recognition" would have been nice. other than that it's a fluid, melodic, and effective poem. it's too bad that we cannot post images next to our poetry; a nice piece of artwork could have made the poem.
Shuushin on lost memories by ggawrysi 12 Apr 2004, 12:55 PM
Quite the American University fan club you've got going there ggawrysi.
ggawrysi on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 1:10 PM
a little melodramatic, but then it is poetry. interesting personification of the sun and a volcano.
ggawrysi on Jesus Rises from the Grove by wilco 12 Apr 2004, 1:12 PM
i don't have any major criticisms or anything that i loved. it entertained me, which is really all that i ask from a poem.
ggawrysi on some deleted poem 12 Apr 2004, 1:17 PM
hailing from NY and being a die-hard Yankees fan, i understand exactly what you intended with this. you have to picture the setting; the immediate six blocks surrounding Yankee Stadium. zodiac, you're over analyzing. one criticism: the poem didn't do too much textually... another stanza, even just a four liner to wrap it up, would have been nice.