poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 5461–5480 back. Include replies to comments

lol on A man’s life (My Life) by lol 5 Jul 2006, 8:28 PM
pls comment
Ranger on What? (Wot?) by ecargo 6 Jul 2006, 2:26 PM
I'll remember to give this a proper read and vote tomorrow.
P.S. Any new recordings recently?
Ranger on Astronomy and Pharmaceuticals by wilco 6 Jul 2006, 2:22 PM
No time for a full-length comment at the moment, je regrette. Great song though.
pollywolly on Destruction by kaoriliveshere 6 Jul 2006, 12:33 PM
this is all a bit crazed and confused a bit like a swarm of bees i guess. was this the idea?
wilco on Patio 95 by ecargo 5 Jul 2006, 8:05 PM
Damn, I really like this and don't even know why.
wilco on canada day by Bill Z Bub 5 Jul 2006, 7:53 PM
The spacing works okay and there's something I like about it...still, just not overly impressed with this one Mr. Devil.
some deleted user on PHOTO by madamefrufru 6 Jul 2006, 5:07 PM
"A moment flickers for silence"--nice line. good poem.
Zoe on Devil's Deal by kaoriliveshere 6 Jul 2006, 12:00 PM
Nice sentiment here. Have you thought about putting it into a rhyming form?
amanda_dcosta on What? (Wot?) by ecargo 5 Jul 2006, 7:38 PM
Is this some kind of a Genesis sequel? .... day, light, word, air, birds, breath, ......???
pollywolly on PHOTO by madamefrufru 6 Jul 2006, 12:42 PM
good solid draft i say could do with some tweaking around the edges to bring it together a bit more. i liked the wording very descriptive
Dovina on Devil's Deal by kaoriliveshere 6 Jul 2006, 4:56 PM
I agree with Zoe. This would go over better with constant rhythm and possibly rhyme. Also, the grammar is wrong in some places. It's the kind of theme that needs a haunting rhythm.
Ranger on Bedlam Bazaar by Zoe 6 Jul 2006, 2:18 PM
More of an interesting Welsh verse than Catatonia managed. You'll be huge in Cardiff; you should read this from a tower in the (almost finally) renovated castle. They have peacocks in there. Poetry and peacocks - what more could we ask for? It takes a lot of practise to be able to read this aloud. Have a read of Nicholas Jones' works.
Why the hell's this been zeroed? Line 13 - "birds".
amanda_dcosta on A Boy Without Rain by D. $ Fontera 5 Jul 2006, 8:18 PM
A nice theme, there, and I like the last four lines.... Pls punctuate. It's like I have to re read to get the right tone and flow of words.
Dovina on Astronomy and Pharmaceuticals by wilco 6 Jul 2006, 3:12 PM
I don't like the opening, "And so." Maybe it sounds right when sung, but it's off-putting in print. Also the mis-grammar, "your eyes reflecting chemicals" may work better in song, than poem. Try the title, "Astonomy and Pharmacy," working off the near-rhyme in Verse 2. After the bridge, it seems to change track, again something that may work well in song, and not so well in a poem.
Dovina on PHOTO by madamefrufru 6 Jul 2006, 5:46 PM
I find this very descriptive and the way of photos. The cold line of phosphorus dates the photograph if you mean those old phosphorus flashes. The fading picture is broken, bitten, boiled - how so? and the last word, "soiled" implies something will soil the picture, but what? I find that those old photos last very long if kept out of sunlight. "I hold a sliver of her soul, Which slowly does decay" - good line.
amanda_dcosta on wait and see by hendrimike 5 Jul 2006, 7:59 PM
Not bad.
amanda_dcosta on good to see you by hendrimike 5 Jul 2006, 7:57 PM
Don't tell that no one's actually voted and commented here. So much for decency! I bet if you had to put one sick word into it you'd have probably got a dozen votes. To nit-pick, I'd like it if there were caps for the 'i'. I personally dislike seeing it in small letters, or maybe I'm too particular about that. It would also be nice if the beginning of verses were also caps. It gives a very disordered look without it, making your piece look less impressive. I'm trying to put a tune to it. Think one could fit in , so ... I could probably say that it's fairly good. The lyrics though, are a little common.
Dovina on Our Lady of the Rock by Zoe 6 Jul 2006, 2:59 PM
I can only guess what this is about, but it doesn't matter. The language is beautiful. The Biblical reference, pulled into modern time, skirts about the expected pact between Sarah and Hagar, and brings in Jacob who really came later. So I really don't feel that connection. But the phrasing is so good that I don't care.