poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 3961–3980 back. Include replies to comments

Dovina on She dreams by amanda_dcosta 24 Nov 2006, 9:30 AM
It has a nice rhythm and a wistful playfulness. "the world without a doubt, as she" could lose "as she" "love unfolds" "of oaks and pine and firs growing tall" seems off rhytrhm. "pines" for consistency. "skip to its tune" is off-grammar, but "skipping" would be off-rhythm.
Dovina on Disposal and Liberation by MacFrantic 24 Nov 2006, 9:39 AM
I've been there and had a similar thought. It's not badly stated.
SupremeDreamer on Celebrity by horus8 24 Nov 2006, 11:32 AM
Here here! Indeed. May want to check some spelling & grammar, but that aside, it makes me shiver with fear and orgasm.
Ranger on She dreams by amanda_dcosta 25 Nov 2006, 1:59 PM
Excellent except for 'of oaks and pines and firs growing tall' - rhythm's out and I'd rather see another way of describing them rather than as being tall. But this is one of your best, without a doubt.
Ranger on Instruction by Dovina 25 Nov 2006, 2:02 PM
'I'd rather do those things/when future world was kind' - tense consistency? Other than that, this is grand. You should live the Ray Mears life.
Ranger on In sickness and in health by Schlinkey 25 Nov 2006, 2:03 PM
Good villanelle.
The double rhyme of spoiled and soiled is distracting, the rest is very readable.
Hello there Luke, my old nemesis, back with a transparently racist and unpleasant poem. Unless it is actually a subtle piece of satire aimed at the current unfathomable media obsession with Muslim women wearing veils.
Dovina on Wish I was a better lover by Prince of Void 25 Nov 2006, 7:35 PM
Without my current glass of wine, I’d say you’re spouting nonsense. As it is, I could meet you for a drink or two in JJ’s dimlit bar, and know exactly what you mean. A lover, after is said, and after all that Stephen Robins says, is meeting over wine and seeing eye to eye.
The world of rhymes is not “naught but jumbled chance.” Poe would not have said so, nor would his raven, Nevermore. Only this poem would and is.
Dovina on Swollen Tongue by MacFrantic 25 Nov 2006, 7:49 PM
I thought it was 1,764. Yes, I'm sure of it. And you will sleep again.
some deleted user on She dreams by amanda_dcosta 26 Nov 2006, 4:09 AM
Very well done Amanda--a refreshing change from some of the stuff thats been posted lately--keep up the good work.
some deleted user on Instruction by Dovina 26 Nov 2006, 4:17 AM
Well done Dovina--holds its own with some of your best. It's nice to read some decent stuff for a change.
pete on Instruction by Dovina 26 Nov 2006, 5:49 PM
"were future world so kind" perhaps? :).....aaahh i see, a sense-timing paradox thing ... nice
Mystically sullen. Kudos for complicity.
Dovina on Raising the nap by howl 26 Nov 2006, 6:12 PM
"pushes it forward" in the first verse tells me to stop reading. The idea isn't bad, but too many words and discontinuous thought.
howl on some deleted poem 27 Nov 2006, 2:08 AM
The second verse is good. The last four lines of the first verse are a bit muddled. I can't really make out what is happening.
howl on Sonnet 2 (Eulogy for a clerk) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 2:12 AM
Like the curate's egg. I don't like 'Your scornful view on things is far too grim;'.
it's good ..and keep going on this way ..don't trun it into other ways
Ranger on Sonnet 2 (Eulogy for a clerk) by Schlinkey 27 Nov 2006, 1:57 PM
Another very readable sonnet, although again I'm unconvinced by the initial internal rhyming - it sets up an expectation that isn't carried through. It needs punctuation after each quote in order to satisfy the grammar nazi, and over here 'clerk' is pronounced 'clark' which screws up your final rhyme, but that's not really an issue. 'Almond eyes' is really good, conjures up cyanide connotations (works well with the death), and the last two lines are well worked.