Jill Stockinger
on Angelic Fornication by The_Third_Isis
21 Dec 2020, 6:22 PM
This moved me. I felt the pain.
I know something of. But not all of. It's why I never criticize you.
She's an icthyologist.
With a flick of the tale, she's off.
Fin
This is my audience. I'm not sure there's ever been another. I have looked. And wished.
So the silence tells a story.
Where have all the flowers gone, long time passing? They have not gone, for they cannot escape. They are somewhere, but not here. Come back, you poets. Comprised of glyphs with radiance, Come get your kudos.
grasping at what might become
some future might have been—
great lines of hope and practical too.
adding comments always goes to the error box. Please fix this.
I find the form confusing.
I kind of want to hear this out loud, ranted on stage, maybe with some jazz behind it. I don't know how well it holds up for me for re-reading, I don't feel like it "wraps up" for me? but maybe it doesn't need to. I really want it to wrap up more, though.
Feels a little clipped to me in places (first two lines set a cadence for me that I then trip on line three).
I like the second view, definitely think it adds something. Though perhaps it would be less on the nose using the word "palm"?
A poetry workshop this evening
allows bringing an outside poem
bringing yours, I requested comments
giving no personal info on you,
and none of our discussion.
They thought the first verse joins the title somehow.
they say it describes Nadine,
that she or it, is a bit wild.
Something happened, they say, before the third verse
something that lasts forever, and is always remembered
so the apparent redundancy of the two words is not.
The last verse, they said,
reinforces importance of the memory.
they like this verse best.
The "quantum" verse was not well understood
nor do I fully get it.
but memory is like that,
takes metaphoric form sometimes
a life remembered as a rainbow
something in quantum space
Loved some of your lines:
especially
"sky will keep, and the sea, it sleeps; "thoughts I thumbnailed to cork board" and "giant redwoods, so old/committed to reach, and be firm"
Felt some of it (especially beginning) did not mesh with the rest, which was like a progressive story of a life. Might be better to start with second stanza, greater impact that way. Possibly?! Like your ending.
Jill Stockinger
on Beached (Or how I learned to give up the day) by Jeremi B. Handrinos
21 Dec 2020, 6:30 PM
LOVED the line:
"The sun had just yoked"- original and excellent!
Some seemed a little lackluster: the lines"whales were sick too" and a little trite: "I saw no foot-steps home"--The first two stanzas are fresh and hardhitting. Rest of poem did not match that power.
Intense. Moving.
Powerful description, strong ending.
Liked it! Sadly, relate to it...
lovely!
well written, great imagery
One line sticks out as not fitting the song, I think:
disliked "Yet since this rotted bad"--Liked all the rest!