poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 24681–24700 back. Include replies to comments

sk8rs_rule_all on The back of a shovel? by horus8 17 Jan 2004, 6:11 PM
Damn, reminds me of my friend....the sad pathetic yet poetic soul.
sk8rs_rule_all on Love is Like a Rose by justjay 17 Jan 2004, 6:13 PM
Eh
sk8rs_rule_all on Love is Like a Rose by justjay 17 Jan 2004, 6:13 PM
I think its good....very....actually
sk8rs_rule_all on If only by sk8rs_rule_all 17 Jan 2004, 6:22 PM
Too many if onlys' in our lives and i figured this would do justice to one of them in some of yours.
zodiac on (Come find me) by zodiac 17 Jan 2004, 6:50 PM
I thought everyone would get this. It's about wanting to be 'found' as a writer. And maybe it's all the Whitman I had to read last week, but now I'm thinking, screw 'em. When we're ready (and by we, I definitely include the present company of fellow fungi -) when we spring to the surface like mushrooms, fully formed, we're going to mop the earth with them. Just watch.
what a strange world you live in???
richa on Doe by OneFingerAnswer 18 Jan 2004, 5:19 AM
Your last one about gayness was too clumsy and didactic. This one is really good, the tone, much more thoughtful.
The first 3/4 verses are good, the end just degenerates.
zodiac on O Endless Angst, Thou Stingeth Me by Goad 18 Jan 2004, 5:44 AM
I like this except for the title, which doesn't have much to do with the poem anyway (at least not as I read it.) I googled (and poetry anthologied) "endless angst" and "stingest" to see if it was a reference to something and only came up with cheesy teenage weblogs. And I'm confused about the lizards. But I agree with everyone who says the last three lines are amazing.
fevriere on Perfect by mytenderrage 18 Jan 2004, 8:52 AM
It's lacking, poetically. It tells rather than showing. I like that you know what you're saying but at the same time I'd rather the words illustrated instead of just plonking down their meaning.
Goad on some deleted poem 18 Jan 2004, 2:22 PM
Isn't it cool how wandering rhymes with pondering? And if you use the right accent, you can even make wondering rhyme with pondering. Sadly however, there is no accent that can make ponderous rhyme with wondrous. It just doesn't work.
zodiac on Jennifer Entire by Goad 18 Jan 2004, 6:03 PM
I like this better than the other one, the winter one. Actually, I like it quite a bit. The "her skirted knees" line is especially good. Also "history is unneeded details that history of / a one apart watching that one part / missing" is clever and not too poetish. And "I know you, etc." for the end. In fact, I don't think the last stanza (after the break) is necessary. It's stronger ending at the ellipses without the ocean image - very capital-R Romantic and anticlimactic. Also, punctuation: continuously abnormal or missing punctuation is nothing new or useful or particularly well-liked in poetry. Look at your favorite writers (unless you're some e.e.cummings holdout or something) and you'll see they all use more-or-less normal sentence punctuation. So you're bold and different. I can promise you: no one's going to appreciate it - sadly. They'll hold it against you. A lot like this. It'll hurt you (like this) and make you feel that they've missed the bigger picture (like this.) Is that what you want? You have a good sound a lot of the time - mostly when you're not slipping into fake Keats-n-Shelley diction and imagery, like the 'bowers' in the other poem. I'd like to see you play around with your voice some. Maybe write fewer big-P 'Poems' and more - I don't know, 'stuff.' Remember Wordsworth: 'incidents and situations from common life... in a selection of language REALLY used by men...' I don't think he always succeeded, but it's what I still aim for every time. Good luck - I mean it, from a former fellow-capital-R Romantic.
Son of dad is the only good part. Do you mind if I steal it for a garage-band name?
zodiac on Tide Pool by middenHeap 18 Jan 2004, 9:14 PM
God, it seems like all I've done is complain about posts today. It's not that. It's just that it's easier but maybe not better to get the compliments out of the way and get to the suggestions. So - it's good. I just got hung up on 'till instead of until and the word 'thing' in the end. Anything but thing and you could be Elizabeth Bishop and a bag of chips.
Patsy on some deleted poem 18 Jan 2004, 10:41 PM
Well, you're honest.
Patsy on The back of a shovel? by horus8 18 Jan 2004, 10:46 PM
writing from real life?
basit_i on Benedict Arnold by Justone 18 Jan 2004, 10:48 PM
"crystal smoke", "cardboard beneath", "slit my balloon, bleeding red as i fell"---these scintillate. "glimpse of past/lessons for future": too much approaching clichee. but, overall, good. salutations.
basit_i on it's all about the aeroplanes by Patsy 18 Jan 2004, 11:38 PM
Snarkily enough, i was about to not-do anything out of caprice at not having a juicy walking-stick. but being gentle is good too, and so i do so in the end anyways. You ascend higher in terms of all. i await future years with expectatory heart-leaps.
Dark Angle on some deleted poem 19 Jan 2004, 1:04 AM
i have a huge crush on a girl named angie too! she goes to ucla!
lukehanney on The Fox by cleverdevice 19 Jan 2004, 4:35 AM
Excellent - I am impressed