Comments byShuushin, 961–980 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

replying on Heretic Haikus by SupremeDreamer 15 Nov 2003, 1:10 AM
that and 3rd.

do a little research on adelaide crapsey for the scoop on cinquain - good stuff. Here's a good example:

"Triad"

These be
Three silent things:
The falling snow ... the hour
Before the dawn ... the mouth of one
Just dead.
replying on Memoirs of a Monk II - Sacred Witness by Don-Quixote 15 Nov 2003, 1:05 AM
:O) thanks.
oh - can you dump my creds line; gives me the heebies.

glad to help though.
replying on Memoirs of a Monk II - Sacred Witness by Don-Quixote 15 Nov 2003, 12:58 AM
sho' nuff. but - also good.
was this yoderian constructed last stanza in the last version? quickly now - make it engrish!
on Inane Muttering by Don-Quixote 15 Nov 2003, 12:35 AM
"occurrence" as it is used is a missed opportunity, methinks. Why were they welcome? (sarcasm aside)

Other than that, pretty frickin' solid.

-9-
on Reflection by Judas kiss 15 Nov 2003, 12:29 AM
i no comprenday "lips which life my down"
I like how you say "you define in a single kiss
The inexpressible"

De-lark the last three lines, and remove the word love once and the whole thing will be better for it.

-7- prolly a good deal higher without the first crit.
on Outhouse by newagepoet2000 15 Nov 2003, 12:26 AM
Hmmmm. stinky, and I'm annoyed at the waste of the precious posting space (not being blessed with multiple user names - and I'm not saying you are either, and besides, it's perfectly legal).

-5- cuz it's the closest thing to a real haiku anyone has posted here in a while (at least it's about nature).
replying on Memoirs of a Monk II - Sacred Witness by Don-Quixote 15 Nov 2003, 12:23 AM
I LOVE titanium.

Glad you liked the delta - some folks round these parts don't take kindly to semicolons though, so - watch yer back...
on You love it. by skaskowski 15 Nov 2003, 12:20 AM
I don't hate it. It's got a fresh format too.

I almost hate the last part, but the others are so good I'm willing to live with it.

and if the "love" in the title has anything to do with tennis scorings, I will re-visit this with a ONE.


-8-
on The Gala Apple by peaceseeker 15 Nov 2003, 12:17 AM
VEry dense. Too dense imho. A few real gems in there and I would have stuck with it if there was some satisfying payoff at the end (pretty much anything except a hand kissed goodnight).

Prolly five really good poems in there.

dig
them
out.

-7-
replying on Memoirs of a Monk II - Sacred Witness by Don-Quixote 15 Nov 2003, 12:10 AM
Suggestion is easy, just flush all the words after the comma.

"just silent observers;
a witness [of] moments repeated"
on Heretic Haikus by SupremeDreamer 15 Nov 2003, 12:08 AM
A nice conceptual run! and your first 'haiku'; good job. Too bad we don't have another classification for 5/7/5 poems.

try these as cinquain (2/4/6/8/2)
-7-
on Good Riddance by dragonfly 14 Nov 2003, 11:55 PM
Hey - this is really pretty good. I'm thinking the rhyming might take away from the seriousness of it, but as it is - it works.

How about another version without rhyme? But keep this one too. -8-
"liquescent" - nice, also: "non compos mentis eye"


I like this - I would like it more without the half sentence after the last comma. -8-
replying on What the fuck is a HAIKU anyway? by titan69 14 Nov 2003, 7:29 AM
What the hell are you talking about? He failed what, now?
on What the fuck is a HAIKU anyway? by titan69 13 Nov 2003, 7:01 PM
Dont get you examples here - they are mostly senryu.
quite a week. yep, quite a week.
Reads pretty good, actually. Sometimes those wings can give a pre-impression.

Couple crits for you, if you are so inclined.

a comma after "decency" would work well overall, methinks

nest-[sites]? or were you making a play on "nasty"; either way.

"bust seats"? what is that? bus seats? if the "nest-sties" was intentional, then I'd believe this was too.

The last two lines are - perfect.
replying on paint me a poem (try 2) by nentwined* 13 Nov 2003, 7:18 AM
(nor do I agree INTRANSIT is a simpleton, btw)