poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 4521–4540 back. Include replies to comments

Hello Edna, I'm going to say this once so I hope you'll pay close attention. What you attempt to pass off on this site as poetry is actually prose written in columns and stanzas -- and pretty silly, sloppy prose at that. You have the mistaken idea, like quite a few young, green, imature "poets," that shocking language and "cutesy" ideas are somehow synonomous with poetry. In your case, however, it's not just bad writing. That I could put up with, given your obviously "new student" level of writing. In your case, it's arrogance as well, and that I have a very hard time overlooking. Not only does it make you look foolish as a person, it makes your work even more silly and unprofessional. Take my word for it. You don't write good poetry. And the "poets" on this or any other site who seem to think you do, are as green and cluelss as you. My suggestion? Drop the "Muse Queen" facade and take a good hard look at yourself and what you're doing (or, rather, trying to do). Then, if you're really serious about the craft, take a few lessons in modesty, find a mentor and study hard, write alot, and set about REALLY learning how to create good poetry. Good luck!
Edna Sweetlove on Soup Can by oneglove 23 Sep 2006, 7:13 PM
Pretty boring.
I fell asleep after stanza #1.
Edna Sweetlove on when enough is too much by elderking 23 Sep 2006, 7:15 PM
Have you heard of capital letters?
If this is poetry, I'm a Chinaman.
Edna Sweetlove on some deleted poem 23 Sep 2006, 7:16 PM
Inconsequential.
Edna Sweetlove on if really its me by Landon2 23 Sep 2006, 7:16 PM
Illiterate garbage.
Edna Sweetlove on some deleted poem 23 Sep 2006, 7:18 PM
Hmm, not exactly fab is it?
Edna Sweetlove on In the hollow (rough) by ecargo 23 Sep 2006, 7:19 PM
What sort of word is "pricker", sweetie? The rest shows promise.
PoeticJustice on Desolation by Beyond_Dreams 24 Sep 2006, 12:18 AM
I really like it. :D
Edna Sweetlove on some deleted poem 24 Sep 2006, 10:29 AM
Having just read your lippy comment on a piece I wrote I thought I'd come and see what you write yourself. Well, well, well. It was even worse than I thought. The word which first springs to mind is "pretentious", the second word is "ungrammatical" and the third word is "tripe". You will be happy to know I shall not bother read anything you write again. You appear to be labouring under the delusion that, to write poetry, you scribble a couple of sentences (if they can be called that as some are bereft of verbs) of dodgy semi-comprehensible illiterate prose and then you break it up into odd little lines. You are wrong. 2/10 for effort. Since I am of a generous nature.
Edna Sweetlove on some deleted poem 24 Sep 2006, 10:31 AM
Oh dear. I shouldn't have bothered.
Edna Sweetlove on I Have, Because I Am by flock 23 Sep 2006, 7:20 PM
Very funny; but deadly boring.
Edna Sweetlove on Rain by flock 23 Sep 2006, 7:20 PM
Pitifully poor.
Edna Sweetlove on SLIM JIM by PodPoet 23 Sep 2006, 7:21 PM
Illiterate and unamusing. I have read better things in a fortune "cookie".
PoeticJustice on Shadows In Your Eyes by PoeticJustice 23 Sep 2006, 7:30 PM
You guys are so mean. I wrote out these feelings and all you care about is the way it reads. But looking from the last 20 comments about all poems, everyone on this site is mean. I could go through everyone elses poems and call their thoughts and feelings badly written and sound smart and clever, but what about the persons feelings that you just hurt from saying things like that when they are trying to get things out there for the world to see and hoping someone will understand? You should all think before you mouth off.
Dovina on Her Eyes by Fayt 24 Sep 2006, 2:49 PM
Here you have writen an outline for the essence of a poem. It is not a poem, but good thoughts that you can make into a poem. Nice start.
funny that someone mentioned rap. i'd really like to hear how this fits a beat and groove. and if it doesn't, change it so it does. for example, "you can go ahead and sound the alarm" could be shortened to "go n' sound the alarm." just an example.
nypoet22 on The Dovina Memorial Bike Lane by Dovina 24 Sep 2006, 6:21 PM
damn right! if i were you i'd rework the line breaks to emphasize more verbs. "abused" is buried in the middle of a line when it needed to be front and center. i think you captured here something we all sometimes wish we could do: pull all the politicians out of their chairs, shake them violently and talk some sense, dammit!
nypoet22 on Pain by PoeticJustice 24 Sep 2006, 6:29 PM
a homocidal arsonist poem? maybe you're just too far ahead of me, but i'm having trouble taking something meaningful from it. i know you have an endrhyme scheme that you feel you need to follow, but before it rhymes this has to bring something more evocative. don't tell about the anger. show it.