Comments byShuushin, 661–680 back. Include replies

on some deleted poem 20 Mar 2004, 3:22 PM
cute.

I think you should build something bigger with it (ifn't you gonna call it a lyric)
on Puritans by zodiac 20 Mar 2004, 6:14 PM
Meaning aside - which is fine, the flow of this is a few extra words past something that I might like very much.

It has a musical flow to it that I often strive for.

But I'm not thrilled with some of the simple descriptors and imagery - while the cadence is melodic, the language is uncomfortable.

Does that make sense?

windy warm
formidable
long and tenderly - could do without those, in particular.
on some deleted poem 20 Mar 2004, 6:17 PM
I was thinking this could make a good ghazal.
on some deleted poem 20 Mar 2004, 6:18 PM
what is this a glosa _of_?
on some deleted poem 21 Mar 2004, 7:44 PM
I like the thought behind this -

I'm going to suggest a word change - and its pretty ironic too, considering what I just posted (and zodiacs love of it) - funny thing is I would suggest the same regardless of what I posted.. anyway...

consider changing "clothes" to "adorns" - both for the word choice and also for the aliteration.

I like "imagining" there.
on Poetry in action by Bobjim 22 Mar 2004, 8:54 AM
nothin says lovin' like a limerick.
on Ramblings of Senility by Lifeboatman 22 Mar 2004, 7:25 PM
Nicely constructed, nicely done.
on urge purged by caffrey 22 Mar 2004, 7:29 PM
I don't "get" the last stanza, but I like the rest quite a bit. I hangs just on that edge of tongue-in-cheek. works for me.
on Zin by caffrey 22 Mar 2004, 7:30 PM
no. Sorry. Too much poetry, not enough profundity.
on Dissenting voice by richa 23 Mar 2004, 8:09 AM
"Kivi veereb"?

I like this one quite a bit - do we need the last line?
on some deleted poem 23 Mar 2004, 10:49 AM
try it on poemosrankeros.com
on some deleted poem 23 Mar 2004, 5:03 PM
Spongebob would be proud.
on some deleted poem 23 Mar 2004, 6:19 PM
yet time has not forgotten,
soft cotton
on some deleted poem 25 Mar 2004, 6:28 AM
What's this about? Conistoga wagons, colony trade?

Feels short.
on Style / Ffordd by Nicholas Jones 25 Mar 2004, 6:30 AM
While you wait for Godot, I wait for poetry.

Actually, this makes a solid point... if only it were SPANISH, well then - ooo that would be sumfin.
on Misplaced Life by Richard 25 Mar 2004, 6:32 AM
"You, a new flavor expanding
Across my windshield."

Richard, for this kind of [sadly very common] subject matter it needs to really stand out to, well, stand out.

Some good imagery here, but not truly striking.
on I'm Alive! by sonawrote 25 Mar 2004, 6:34 AM
Hey - not a bad hook. Could make a good song.
on Reunion by syrusstone 25 Mar 2004, 6:36 AM
hmmmm.... some line breaks would give this a better flow.

Some fresh thoughts on a pretty common theme.
on My reflection by singinkygal 22 Mar 2004, 7:57 PM
I'm going to echo caffrey - but elaborate by saying the “too many” words are precisely the ones you've put in to sound like “poetry”.

Here's a test - take out the rhyming words - does the meaning change? If it doesn't - why have them?

You word choices should add value. You've got shattered twice, btw - and five "t"'s between them. And my pet peeve, extraneous prepositional phrases.

Try not to trade meaning for rhyme – what you are trying to convey (the idea of which I like, btw) is complicated enough as it is – focus on that.

Maybe, as an exercise, make the same poem without rhyming?