CommentsComments 14001–14020 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

zodiac replying on Due Consideration by Dovina 23 Nov 2005, 11:35 PM
On slate.com. Just enter any of the of above in quotes on yahoo or google.
zodiac replying on Letter from Palermo by Caducus 23 Nov 2005, 11:31 PM
No. I'm a special education teacher in the middle of the Jordanian desert. But I did study poetry for about 7 years of college. 1) What you're lacking most is consistency to your metaphors. You often pick one aspect of an image that relates to the thing you're describing, but ignore the other aspects of it that don't relate at all. For instance, in a recent poem you called child prostitutes "painted masterpieces" when the only thing about masterpieces that resembles child prostitutes is something like "painted up to please the viewer"; all other aspects of masterpieces, like "product of hard work and creative genius, appealing on dozens of sublime and intellectual levels, painted by respectable people" totally work against what you're trying to get across about prostitutes. A corollary of this, though not as necessary, is consistency between metaphors. For example, in this poem you have things compared to rivers and zombies like, two lines apart. It's not such a crime, but ideally there'd be some kind of logic or connection between them. That's all I can do right now. I'll get back on the rest.
Dovina replying on Math Poem 4 by Dovina 23 Nov 2005, 11:22 AM
“Flapping around Alpha Beta” happens sometimes during the test of a mechanical pterodactyl. I don’t undertake only those tasks at which I believe I will shine. Such fear-based reticence would limit my fun. You do understand that we play a child’s game aimed at education. I risk encountering ridicule, and even welcome it sometimes, for the possibility of a shining insight. It’s hard to be sworn at or likened to all manner of disgusting things. But the way I see it, as long as sun glimmers from a pool of urine, I’ll endure the stench. Or as a lost friend once said, “Poemranker is a great resource. It is like a huge thrift shop or, even better, a gigantic landfill. If you don't mind getting dirty, there are many precious things to be found under some especially slimy, fecally covered toilet seat or unwashed, skidmarked underwear.” I’m getting all mushy and teary-eyed now. I hope at least one person reading this ramble has experienced courage not his or her own – realizes that this is an essay born in love. I plan to show it to him this evening and tell him that to feel loved is to feel worth more than the sum of my efforts, and that his brief words counteract an ocean of guff. Thanks for listening.
ALChemy replying on The Fall of Marvin Hyde by cyan9 23 Nov 2005, 10:26 AM
I see. The body creates it's own highly addictive drugs and this can usually be sited as a main factor in why people will do things that make them appear to be on synthetic drugs. I'm glad to hear that this is coming from a sober mind. Somehow it seems to make the poem better knowing that.
cyan9 replying on The Fall of Marvin Hyde by cyan9 23 Nov 2005, 8:15 AM
It'll be like the film how to get a head in advertising, she'll appear as a boil in your neck that you try to lance, but winds up growing into a new head that lances you and buries your head as a boil in your neck..... or maybe not.
cyan9 replying on The Fall of Marvin Hyde by cyan9 23 Nov 2005, 8:12 AM
The line about the junkie and his syringe has little to do with herion, and more to do with a state of craving pain. + I have taken many substances and been temporarily hooked on a few, but not heroin.
cyan9 replying on The Fall of Marvin Hyde by cyan9 23 Nov 2005, 8:09 AM
This piece is a exaggeration of a period in my life well prior to taking any drugs, I don't take any now either. Heroin addicts are 'fucked up' people; having seen what Ive seen, I blame the reasons for them being 'fucked up' rather than the drug that can provide benefit to generally the terminally ill.
cyan9 on Lines by OneFingerAnswer 23 Nov 2005, 7:55 AM
Something that I think everyone thinks at some point, put very clearly, although the last line one would suppose should mean that your tongue was trying to trick you; except your tongue tripping over imples that somebody else had caught you.... perhaps a little more than meets the eye here, or someone looking to hard???
cyan9 replying on The Rise of Dr Herbert Cyan by cyan9 23 Nov 2005, 7:46 AM
Ahem errrrr hum oh yes duh
Dovina on The Rise of Dr Herbert Cyan by cyan9 23 Nov 2005, 7:40 AM
I take the good doctor as a creation of the character Marvyn Hyde. (You need to change the footnote.) It portrays for me the process of self reinvention, which I can relate to. Alchemy thought you were talking about drugs, and maybe you are.
Dovina replying on Waiting For The Light To Change by elderking 23 Nov 2005, 7:31 AM
You must have clicked on the little red x. There is no recovery from such sin.
Dovina replying on Sonata for Robin and Poet by Dovina 23 Nov 2005, 7:27 AM
Your powms do not show up on the random list because they have been voted on recently. Only poems without votes show up there. Sorry about Caviot, it should be Caveat. You'll get a lot more guff comments here on Poemranker than comments on your poem. If you like the interchange, that's good, if not you'll be disappointed. I try to sort gems from a trash heap, and figure the take is worth the effort.
Dovina on No Worries by Dovina 23 Nov 2005, 7:17 AM
I have been accused, elsewhere on Poemranker, of plagiarizing this poem. I ask you, has plagiarism occurred when I cite the source and describe how I use it?
ay deee replying on i dream in nine minute increments by ay deee 23 Nov 2005, 5:24 AM
oh, ok. i don't like the way capitalizing looks most of the time. maybe it's word equality. monospace fonts are my favorite; monoheight letters look like they fit here...
ALChemy replying on i dream in nine minute increments by ay deee 23 Nov 2005, 5:14 AM
Nightmare On Elm Street. Cheap joke. I wasn't trying to say anything bad about your poem. The dream logic in it is pretty good. Is there a specific reason for not capitalizing?
ALChemy replying on Us Sinners by BrandonW 23 Nov 2005, 5:07 AM
I'm saddened that you don't trust me after all this time. :(
FreeFormFixation replying on rubble rooster by FreeFormFixation 23 Nov 2005, 3:52 AM
wow, i really like that. damn it, why cant i live in jamaica already? nice visit...and... i want to live there.
cyan9 on Derrick Holmes by rahson_s 23 Nov 2005, 1:50 AM
Sin City. Captivates the feel of gangster talk from films, I thought there were places where the piece could benefit from more elaberate use of language e.g we Moved the bodies to the car outside seating two Italian >>> We packed the stiffs in the motor Outside seating two butch mafiosos -pardon the spelling-
cyan9 replying on Sonata for Robin and Poet by Dovina 23 Nov 2005, 1:42 AM
What does Caviot mean by the way? I cant find it in any dictionary's.
cyan9 replying on Sonata for Robin and Poet by Dovina 23 Nov 2005, 1:38 AM
There is one problem with your argument here, being that once a poem is off the recent list, it tends not to be red, and just seems to sit there as a bad egg taking up space. It is not an issue of sensitivity, and if it were, there would be nothing to be sensitive about apart from the lack of comments. I only receive votes on new poems, perhaps because I have massively less work on this site, mine do not appear on random so often. Never the less. The reason I deleted the piece in question was that it had a lot of hits with the only comments being about whether you should vote or not, one vote from you, and another from someone to negate your 5, leaving the piece unconsidered and thus it was better to replace it with something that might be considered, allowing me to figure out what is and isn't accessible for people.