poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 4801–4820 back. Include replies to comments

nypoet22 on Exposing Anne Frank by Caducus 9 Sep 2006, 3:31 AM
clever! very tight writing and good depth, even on a well-worn path.
nypoet22 on Products of Pacifisim by Nuit 9 Sep 2006, 3:37 AM
i like the sentiment a lot, and i agree with the main points. But somehow the poem itself really doesn't move me. needs some sort of concrete imagery to give the invective grounding. worry not though, this is just one lunatic's opinion.
nypoet22 on SLIM JIM by PodPoet 9 Sep 2006, 3:40 AM
i don't get it.
nypoet22 on darabuka by skaskowski 9 Sep 2006, 4:01 AM
i liked the recurring "lay low" to begin stanzas. it seems to me that refrain was abandoned far too early in the poem, which turns into a loose stream-of-consciousness type rant without a focal point. this seems to be going somewhere good, but right now there's just no focus.
nypoet22 on Epistemology (2nd draft) by Ranger 9 Sep 2006, 5:12 AM
overall i like this.
nypoet22 on Hailing Miriam by Ranger 9 Sep 2006, 5:15 AM
i wonder how many readers understand the historical significance here. this is very well thought out. my suggestion would be to have liner notes like eliot, explaining the references.
Ranger on some deleted poem 9 Sep 2006, 12:51 PM
Argh, I'm so close to getting this without having to pick at it. Is this an anti-political-correctness poem, or an anti-establishment poem?
Ranger on weather poem part 11: the muffin by nypoet22 8 Sep 2006, 11:39 PM
The first line is class and the imagery in here is pretty unique to the subject, I think. Lines 8 and 9, although fun, seem a little...erm...simple, maybe, in comparison with the rest? The content is good there but I'd have preferred it to be rephrased. Other than that, I thoroughly enjoyed this :-)
Ulterius on Limp Cock by Edna Sweetlove 9 Sep 2006, 2:27 AM
The 'splat' at the end is a new addition, I believe, and a very good one, also. Amusing and repulsive.
nypoet22 on Singing by ThereseWaneck 9 Sep 2006, 2:46 AM
i feel ya. sloshin' is a weak beginning though; reverse the order of lines 1 and 2. last stanza rocks rocks rocks.
What a lovely homecoming! I must say, your life sounds far more exciting than mine. However, I must be an anus, because 'Farting In A Cathedral' still gets me every time, and is my favourite of your poems. Perhaps it is the highly amusing audio version of it which helps.
grotesque. captivating. wan autumn's fart is superb. lines 3 and 4 don't add anything useful. middle 2 stanzas are pretty clever. very original stuff for the most part, but for me the gross-out factor ends up killing it at the end.
Ulterius on hate by ts 9 Sep 2006, 3:42 AM
I've seen better things written in shit on public toilets. Even without the ridiculous spelling errors you still have no originality and no rhyme scheme. I expect you'll enjoy this comment, however, as it will give the opportunity to write a poem about 'tht fkn btch hu slagd of mi poem, lyk.' Go on. Slag me off. I dare you. Utter tripe, and well deserving of being in the 'worst.'
nypoet22 on Alone by T'ien 9 Sep 2006, 4:18 AM
you could have done SO much more with this.
nypoet22 on my brother's by joey 9 Sep 2006, 4:20 AM
repost this in "limerick"
nypoet22 on Jesus by Sing4Jesus! 9 Sep 2006, 4:25 AM
umm, ok.
The story in here is good - from experience (partly/entirely)? I tend to find that lyrics are difficult to rate in purely written form; their effectiveness is substantially down to the music involved. The following song is the ultimate example of it - average poetry, but utterly stunning when set to music: http://www.lyricscafe.com/p/porcupine_tree/061.htm (beware popups...) for the lyrics, if you can download it, the band is Porcupine Tree and the song is Heartattack In A Layby. **shameless plug over** What's the deal with the title - 'weather poem'?
Ranger on Products of Pacifisim by Nuit 9 Sep 2006, 12:33 PM
So are you saying that religious wars make for a more interesting life? That's what I'm taking from this poem.
i somehow have the sense that i've seen this form before. or maybe it's just a bit similar to other forms. in any case the repetition works very well. the topic is a little on the cutesy side, but it's blunt, tight and well-addressed. one may criticize the poem as insensitive to the issues dealt with by the obese, but anyone who can't figure out the point probably needs hooked on phonics.
nypoet22 on With Old Light by Ranger 9 Sep 2006, 1:55 PM
i love the way you construct the stanzas; it feels very natural as endrhymes go. i do agree with your own comment about a dearth of metaphor, but that doesn't detract much.