Ranger
on Sensually Literary Villanelle by bwaha
16 Apr 2007, 1:49 AM
Still good, what was changed?
You might want to trim a few commas - and richa's got a point about the 'tears shed' line. If you were to enjamb that line it would help the stanza flow a bit more as well.
I like this. Of the two refrains 'my favourite lover, English, is great in bed' is by far the best. A couple of places where it loses its discipline. 'I pity romancers who have tears shed' is forced. And the fifth verse isn't as good as the others.
I culled this list from your first couple of verses. With the exception of perhaps "bitterness" and "insane" you are stuck at an elementary vocabulary level. Unless you are going for pimple(in which case, categorize it as such), it would be helpful to spice up your language. Use some vivid and evocative words that specifically pin point how you are feeling.
Like, when you said there would be "loneliness, bitterness, and pain" - I know you can dig deeper than that! There are a lot of different ways to be lonely or be in pain. The reader isn't going to be able to intensely identify with those words.
So get more specific. Tell us exactly what the bitterness and pain would be like. Draw the reader in so they truly can identify.
^.^
~~~Megan
How does something "[mock] to and fro"?...That line confuses me, slightly.
Why is everyone writing rubish poems about other users all of a sudden they're not funny, or clever, or good. It is a practice I will be mentioning to nentwined in our next conference call on the future of this website. We are currently planning to go for an IPO in the Summer on the proviso we can get rid of some of the more stale old crones who haunt the halls of this institution.
I like it
hmmm.
lose the "so" in line 3. it just doesn't work somehow.
i like where this goes, and it opens a host of discussion points about humanity, good and evil, etc. maybe the last word should be "sin", and then we can really throw some fuel on the fire, eh?
Life
....love the changes you made :).
In my opinion, they take this from simply good, to excellent. ^.^
I think you want a period after bed in S4. L2,S5 needs a more descriptive last word I think; and "so" is a weak word. Otherwise this is unique and good.
lol!
There is no way in the seven hells that I can give this anything less than a ten
This is the best thing you have posted recently.
Are you writing poems about the luminaries on this excellent site? Please write about me next.
How delightfully apposite!
RockMage, this is a sad attack.
Could you not attempt something better? This certainly is not kosher. Plus it's evident that he can write, simply perview his postings; there used to be more than what is shown now by the way, until he decided to delete a large portion of it... but in any case, whatever angle you attempt, it will have little or no effect. Belittling him, in essence, is simply the act of belittling yourself. But, by all means, do what you feel necessary.
there is no point or thought in this
i cannot see any reason why this line should read as such:
"new doors He opens"
there is no rhyme that it is matching up with, but the effect of the flow is rather devastating. perhaps rework it to a more "normalized" sytax?
Wouldn't it mean the same if you shortened it:
Start separately
Become one
She takes all your stuff
But then it wouldn't be 5-7-5. Pity.
There's a good sentiment here that could be a good poem. Get rid of half the commas (faith, that - for example); clean up the grammar; and get rid of excess words (now in the last line, just in the penultimate line) and fix the spelling - families, their.