poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 21821–21840 back. Include replies to comments

zodiac on Suicide Girl by wilco 17 Apr 2004, 6:44 AM
For everyone who doesn't already know, Elliott Smith committed suicide by stabbing himself in the chest with a knife.
zodiac on Temporal by Shardik 17 Apr 2004, 6:41 AM
Hot damn!
some deleted user on some deleted poem 16 Apr 2004, 1:43 PM
The beginning and the end grab me with a cozy feeling of verisimilitude. If oNLy the midDLe kEPt paCE, I think you'd have something.
you might find your soul buried beneath your language skills if you bothered to look for them. I think the lack of sensation left in the wake of pain is a theme that CAN be handled without cliche, but it takes flawless execution to do so. And a bit more imagination.
it appears the real play is acted out in the gallery.
oftherealm on Diptych by coffeespoons 16 Apr 2004, 3:40 PM
so lovely to read. i give it an eight.
some deleted user on This > That...Why? by MacFrantic 16 Apr 2004, 8:40 PM
Live life fast and get more life. Is that it? Well you've said it well, but it doesn't fit my frying pan. Slow and easy gets more done, I say.
tadpole on when do dreams fade? by francis nor capule 16 Apr 2004, 9:53 PM
I really like it
Shuushin on Suicide Girl by wilco 17 Apr 2004, 9:18 AM
i really think you could improve the broken car simile - other than that, really well done.
Shuushin on Temporal by Shardik 17 Apr 2004, 9:21 AM
something here stumps me: "And shadows curling through vista The river, black, snaked in daylight." captital v on vanilla? even with those nits - a rockin 9
Shuushin on Summers Breath on my neck by unouluvme 17 Apr 2004, 9:22 AM
would be cool if u made this from the perspective of a small rodent.
Sasha on some deleted poem 17 Apr 2004, 9:44 AM
This reminds me, in style though not in message, of W.S. Merwin I give this poem a seven in part because it is frank, with little imagery which is not a vice in and of itself (if it were Pushkin would not be the great poet he is) but also, the words do not seem to use their sound to enhance the poem and to conjure up the thought for themselves. What I mean by this can be better illustrated by example. Take Robert Frost when talking about a woman who slept with a nightlight on: Good gloom on her was thrown away. These sounds work together perfectly and inimitably. One feels they are somehow "right" for what is said. If you don't use a lot of imagery, try for what I am tempted to call word-music
Sasha on some deleted poem 17 Apr 2004, 9:56 AM
I'm sorry, but this is prose with line-breaks.
Sasha on some deleted poem 17 Apr 2004, 10:02 AM
Better. 8 Now the mad ocean breaks his teeth on stone
Sasha on some deleted poem 17 Apr 2004, 10:05 AM
I'm not sure why, but the word "penumbrally" doesen't seem to work in its place when the stress is shifted over to the secondary accent for rhyme's sake
Shuushin on some deleted poem 17 Apr 2004, 10:06 AM
I like "benumbing". and now for the other Khrushchevian shoe, comrade: "throw spikes up" reminds one too much of vomit, and the "up" if you weren't counting sylables would never have stayed. And it implies the trees are performing some action, rather than presenting an image. Maybe thats the idea, that we readers happen upon this scene as the trees push through the earth vomiting spikes [up]. Then after they are like torture racks, the same trees are like wheels - that groan [away]. More lousy tacked on prepositions - newbie mistakes. This thing screams out "I don't want to be a sonnet, please take all this gratuitus fluff and burn it like a book of matches that burn like a puppy left too close to a very hot, flaming object, like a fireplace.
Sasha on some deleted poem 17 Apr 2004, 10:27 AM
You're quite right about that there, angst is all it is. I don't claim that it is anything else. What prepositions exactly?
cool title, engaging read. Was this a rewrite?
Well written, has a nice feel. I am left a little confused by the ending. You go from language as fire to language as soft stanzas to language as the wind.
richa on forgetful dyke by elizabethann 17 Apr 2004, 11:04 AM
It is OK, relating of a fairly meaningless but nevertheless charming story. By the way unless your mum is a soul reever I very much doubt she 'brought you to life'.