poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 7001–7020 back. Include replies to comments

Niphredil on _The Black Prince_ by Caducus 9 Mar 2006, 11:38 AM
This is extremely good. However, I disagree with Ranger in that it still needs some work. First and foremost, 'Seppuku' jarred on me intensely because I had envisioned a medieval setting; it doesn't seem to harmonize at all with the rest of the poem. In addition, shouldn't "conquered by I" be "conquered by me; the Black Prince"? Not until I had read the poem again did I notice that the narrator was forced to conquer the kingdom; but the other prince was greeted by cheer(s?) and garlands. I guess he had it easier...
Ranger on the comet by pollywolly 9 Mar 2006, 11:56 AM
Quite cool, but you could probably turn this into a concrete poem. Which would be definitely cool. I liked the ending.
BenRice on the comet by pollywolly 9 Mar 2006, 12:52 PM
I liked the first stanza and not the second. The bit of repetition in the first worked for me as did the rhyming of eye and sky. The second verse seems a bit lazy to me compared to the imagery of the first.
Ranger on Stella 130 by BenRice 9 Mar 2006, 1:42 PM
There's good potential here, but it's not quite living up to the promise it shows in places. 'Wires invade my couch' is good, made me think of springs sticking through the fabric. However, 'cat-poop' and 'moo-ing' in particular are (in my opinion) crying out to be replaced by something a little more...well, poetic. Still, a nice sentiment.
Very clever bit of prose here - I like it a lot. Could use just a few less words. "Top-hat velvet" and "soft-shoe shine", "where time is a circle" (and others) read (and sound) so well. Good job young poet! Please keep writing.
BenRice on The Ocean by Fayt 9 Mar 2006, 12:43 PM
Usually a haiku has a sort of pause or break after either the first or second line. This one doesn't, but in this case I think it works because of the continual movement of the waves. I'm not a fan of the last line though. The word "Salty" works against it (I don't think salty water as life-giving). It sounds a bit trite too, "to all"? really? With the right change in that last line, this could be a very good haiku, imho.
BenRice on Spring Rolls by Ranger 9 Mar 2006, 1:00 PM
Clever. The word "pastry" ... just doesn't strike me as the right word, but I can't come up with something better, so maybe it is. "biting" cold... hmm not quite right with me either, but maybe that is just spring in Colorado. The spring roll metaphor works to evoke the variety of weather, color and life of spring.
BenRice on A Short Letter by Ranger 9 Mar 2006, 1:13 PM
I tripped over some extra syllables on some lines. Felt a bit awkward for a limerick. At first I thought, "Byron or Chaucer"? Why not choose authors who used the limerick? But then, the speaker isn't wishing he were a limerick writer - he's wishing he were more eloquent than the simple limerick.
Dovina on Stella 130 by BenRice 9 Mar 2006, 1:33 PM
A good-dog poem, but a bit wordy and cumbersome, i.e.: "If coal is black" seems trite. Why not just "As coal . . . "greyhounds that race" could drop the "that." "long tail is wagged" Passive voice could be made active. And If her name is stella, why not make it the last word?
Ranger on Sour Apple by ecargo 9 Mar 2006, 1:36 PM
This is very groovy, it appeals to my sense of taste (no pun intended) as I'm sure you expected! I'd have liked to see the rhyme continued over stanza 3...although it's loose throughout the piece, it gets too loose there. Stanza 1 gave me the impression of violence, that seemed carried over stanza 2 as well (glassed, jagged etc.). Stanza 4 is excellent, vanity of fairytales always makes for superb imagery. With 'a copse of beeches, damascened' is there supposed to be the play on 'damsel' and 'damson' (damsel relating to the fairytale, damson relating to the 'foresty' theme there)? Because I read it that way - aided by a misreading of 'damascened' on first sight. I love the literal use of damascened there as well - nicely original. 8 for now, I feel that stanza 3 is in need of a little surgery to get up to the standard of the rest.
Dovina on the comet by pollywolly 9 Mar 2006, 1:37 PM
Does it really fly? is it a burning sphere? and it draws nearer or farer, I do believe.
ecargo on Stella 130 by BenRice 9 Mar 2006, 2:22 PM
Cute idea, to twist Sonnet 130 so that it's about a dog, but execution's off. You lose iambic pentameter in line 2; "dogs'" in line one shouldn't be possessive, some other things--but those are just nits. Mostly i think it just needs more original language, particularly st. 3 (nails on chalkboards a cliche; so's "epitome of grace," really, and the long tail causing mayhem--things like that). Welcome back, btw.
Dental Panic on Read me by mystic enoch 9 Mar 2006, 6:30 PM
I disagree with Ranger. I think this is very strong, crude and pure. Just cut the part where you start about poetry. I read you. You got me. Who soothes my thumpin', bumpin' brain? Nobody
Dental Panic on Piano by Dovina 9 Mar 2006, 6:56 PM
'Every line a steppingstone, good for climbing up and down. Boy, is climbing fun, she says, does it ever get you jazzed, fine-tuned and ready for chords' you almost had it there - shame the fifth line didn't make it. using monster/monstrous - too much. The word gets deflated. I think the story is okay but the ending is poor. As if you were through but the poem wasn't.
Dental Panic on _The Black Prince_ by Caducus 9 Mar 2006, 5:51 PM
To me this is just a piece of pretentious crap. Jeering winds that whisper seppuku? Imagine how that sounds: like someone has knocked its front teeth out. sssseppuku... 'surrendering my flesh for lips that became my war cry.' Yeah, life's a bitch.
I like this - most people won't get it - thinking it quite vulgar or invidious. This has a raw dark art to it that reads (and sounds) beautifully.
matt door on Goldmunds Slut Fiasco. by SupremeDreamer 9 Mar 2006, 8:11 PM
Not sure about this as a whole - but sure of it's power by degrees. Pretty cool snack!
This is nice as a tribute, although grammatically it needs improvement. 'To siege' doesn't work - you can use siege as a verb, but it becomes 'besiege'. If you want it as a noun, put a comma after it "To siege, off beyond..." 'Up the fore' doesn't work either, I don't think. 'To the fore' would be fine though. Lines 4-6 I think I know what you mean but the wording is awkward. Also 'Colombia'. I think there are a couple of other corrections that need making, but I'll let someone else spot them. I really like the talk of seven seas/wonders/capes/sages, and 'the seven pearls of Colombia' is a great line. So is 'perhaps in pursuit of capes of ether'. Keep working at this one, it promises to be a really good poem!
Ranger on some deleted poem 10 Mar 2006, 3:52 AM
This is pretty cool, and I like it a lot. Good use of the subject matter, and not overburdened with unnecessary emotion. In my view, 'living corpse roams to nowhere' doesn't quite work. You don't need 'living', and 'roams to nowhere' could be better, but having said that I can't think of anything better straight away. Also - the last line. I got your feelings from it, I got the sadness and distance...but the line is bulky. See if you can find a way of being a little more concise in the last line. Other than that - good!
Blue Magpie on Last flight of a goose by Bobjim 10 Mar 2006, 5:03 AM
I would have said 'the goose' as this is more emphatic