Stephen Robins
on The Prodigal Daughter by Dovina
19 May 2006, 8:03 AM
like a germ laden hanky deposited NEXT to a bin.
I like it. especially the last line, which I think says it all.
Great imagery in this--as there is in most of your work.
looks like a copy and paste that went horribly wrong -
a shame as some of its okay but t be honest it gave me cataracts :-&
Sorry this one made me dizzy and like my boss needs a makeover.
Your problem here i think is the story overbears th epoetry within it.
C'mon Dovina love gimmee a Dovina special.
ahhhh Goa the place where one attractive woman attracts a zillion indian men with fruit and cheap ornaments.
Lovely people, lovely place and good to see a poem on it.
Leave poemranker out though - it has no place in Goa :)
I like the way you voted for yourslf but to give it authenticity you voted 8 rather than 10. However, for a proper spasm of reality why not give it a proper vote of -3-!
I arc a rope of cum in your eye and lauch as you wince.
I like it upo to the last line, which preaches.
Also, the title bothers me because it is not about numbers or addition or zero, but about sewing and reaping perhaps, or about not killing the bastard after his first murder, or about not killing in the name of justice - something like that.
I don't know why she swallowed the spider
that wiggled and jiggled and giggled inside her.
I read this poem for what it was, very clear & simple. Sweet & short. But...I do expect love-inspired poetry to slightly move me, & this was a bit mundane for my tastes, please don't take this personally. Maybe you could establish a pattern with a repitition of first lines in each stanza as "I feel..." perhaps for example.
I felt a bit of random scattered thought pouring onto paper, without precision & passion. Please don't take this the wrong way, I'm just trying to be of some help...if any at all.
~Sunny
I found this to be a very clean piece, although I am one of 'those' who doesn't really care for caps w/ each new line, but I can still look past this of course. I like circles. I like circular stories...so is life, isn't it?!
My own personal notes:
-L2S1: I think starting out the line with "For" is unnecessary & reads awkwardly
-The play again & again of humility such as bringing up the van they were in repeatedly & such word usage as "...the best little farm..." is very nicely played on
-This is a "growth poem" per say - I liked that
-Didn't like how the "forest HEATED her home"...just didn't click w/ me
-Don't feel SHE needs to be screamed out in all caps. I don't feel that way in any instance in poetry however, just me.
-Good ending. Sharp & unpredictable, reading line by line
~Sunny
some deleted user
on some deleted poem
20 May 2006, 2:16 PM
Is this true? Even if it's not it's a damn good poem.
i love the last two lines.
These mathmatical and number poems just don't do it for me.
Total bilge.
i like this; my vote now is not set in stone. i think this has more potential...
some thoughts:
the purist in me would arrange so each time a number is mentioned it is the beginning of a new line. i would count the "nothing" as a number...
i am not sure what the intent is, but there is potential for it to have a more powerful impact. not sure exactly how... maybe with more of the "four tears, sixteen smiles" sort of imagery that tells us of the emotion.
"four tears" could all be from one eye otr two, no?
maybe "thirty-two dry eyes" instead of sixteen smiles; i cannot imagine that many people smiling at an execution, even if they do want to see the guy dead.
i like the concept of the title, but it may be a little to literal. maybe drop out "numbers" or try "sum of nothing", "nothing totalled" , etc.
AH! "empty tally", that's my choice.