poemranker ::The Prodigal Daughter by Dovina

DetailsThe poem, its numbers, and the conversation.

Free verse № 143177

The Prodigal Daughter

Member since 2004 · Posted 15 May 2006 · Edited 15 May 2006 · 27 comments

She asked her Daddy for a hug and a kiss For she was off with a man in a van Educated, working, enriched with skill She knew her life’s pattern; her ethics were set He wept as he held her and gave her a kiss Said only he’d rather she not go like this With a man in a van to search for a home To look for the best little farm in the land So she left with a plan, lots of hope and a man Sat beside him gazing at houses and land For six months they traveled, checked prices and work Then settled in the hills of mid Tennessee She invited her father to see how she’d done He came to the cornrows, tobacco, and cows And walked in the forest that heated her home He sat by her fire and said it was good Seven years later she came groveling home The farm a success, the house they’d built cozy But her man found another and left her alone Now she came groping, her plan gone amok Her father forgave her, took her back in Now SHE cried when he hugged her and kissed Still young and healthy, in search of a plan Now she will ask him about each new man

Rate it

0 is the worst, 10 the best. Pick a number, add a comment if you like, then send it. Keys: 0–9 pick, Enter sends.

mean 6.18 weighted 5.59 rank 2325 views 290 View voting details →

11 votes so far. Yours would make 12.11 votes so far

27 comments

[8] Ranger 15-May-06/10:43 AM Reply
Nice work. There's a typo in line 12, and I don't like the capitalisation of 'she' toward the end; it could just be the font, but generally speaking I'm not a fan of capitalisation for emphasis. It's usually unnecessary. The other thing is that I remember ecargo saying to me in one of my poems that the rhymes were somewhat distracting - I think the same applies here. On my reading it would have gone a little more smoothly without the rhymes. Others may disagree though.

That's the nitpicks done, now for the credit. The story is very well told, concise but not vague - which isn't easy to achieve. It's very tactile as well; I can see the scenes pretty clearly.

Question: the last line - 'would'. Being conditional, I'm a little confused as to this. It seems that there's something preventing her asking (almost like he's dead) but up till then there was nothing to suggest such an eventuality. Might it work better as 'will'?
[n/a] Dovina › Ranger 15-May-06/11:20 AM Reply
Thanks for your comments. I fixed the typo in Line 12. I changed “would” to “will” in the last line for clarification. The “SHE” for emphasis is the way I would read it aloud, to contrast with her father's weeping Line 5. But it looks audacious on paper, and I see your point about capitalization not being needed. I would use italics if that were an option in Poemranker.
[8] Ranger › Dovina 15-May-06/1:45 PM Reply
Ah, okay - agreed the italics would work better in this instance. It's much clearer with 'will' instead of 'would'.

I got your message by the way - am busy writing on there at the moment, but I will reply asap.
[10] ALChemy › Ranger 16-May-06/6:44 AM Reply
or "she" in quotations.
[4] Edna Sweetlove 15-May-06/4:49 PM Reply
You could do with some punctuation.
[8] amanda_dcosta › Edna Sweetlove 15-May-06/10:23 PM Reply
Edna, I think you aught to give a bit of consideration to the content of the poem, and the depth of emotion related to it, rather than only to nit-picking punctuations.
[10] ALChemy › Edna Sweetlove 16-May-06/6:41 AM Reply
Admit it, you're just mad 'cause she only let her father get to first base.
[n/a] Dovina › ALChemy 16-May-06/12:38 PM Reply
Welcome back. But only when you're on my side.
[8] amanda_dcosta 15-May-06/10:19 PM Reply
Very heartfelt and beautiful. I'd like it too if there was enough punctuation. And the partial rhyme scheme is distracting. Nevertheless, I think you deserve nothing less than an 8.
[n/a] Dovina › amanda_dcosta 16-May-06/12:36 PM Reply
Regarding punctuation: In many of my poems, I do not put commas and periods at the ends of lines, where, grammatically speaking, they should be. I want the reader to pause at the end of each line. I think it makes the poem look better on paper.
[7] Niphredil 16-May-06/4:52 AM Reply
Sorry, personally I didn't care for this. It sounds a tad preachy and not original enough by far. I also found the "maybe-yes, maybe-no" rhyming distracting.

Nitpick: Why does her father need to forgive her in the stanza before last? He already did in the second stanza. He even came visiting.
[10] ALChemy 16-May-06/6:38 AM Reply
There's a slight Dr. Suess quality in your rhythm that intentional or not is freekin' ingenious.
[8] Ranger › ALChemy 16-May-06/6:58 AM Reply
The Dr. is an enduring legend, anyone who can emulate him deserves fair recognition.
[10] ALChemy › Ranger 16-May-06/7:20 AM Reply
No one can emulate him in my mind. No one else would spend months limited to using only a 3rd grade vocabulary to write such perfectly unforgetable poetry.
[n/a] Dovina › ALChemy 16-May-06/12:35 PM Reply
We are both lovers of Seuss, and lovers of vacation, apparently. You must just have returned from some horrible dive into depravity, otherwise you would have explained your absence. Such explanations are expected of any reputable ranker. I, striving for some degree of honor, hereby advise everyone that on 5/25 I will depart this prestigious site in favor of two months of bicycling in Canada, and will check in here only occasionally.

But I can’t be too harsh, having just received a flattering 10. For that I thank you and return a little Seuss: “Just say what you want. You want pickles on trees? Want to swing through the air on a flying trapeze? Just say what you want, and whatever you say, you’ll get on Octember the First.”
[10] ALChemy › Dovina 17-May-06/7:05 AM Reply
I already told you I was out of internet.
I meant what I said and I said what I meant.
I lost internet... 100 percent.
[n/a] Dovina › Ranger 16-May-06/12:36 PM Reply
Frankly, I only saw that I was acting like Seuss after Alchemy mentioned it. I found a stack of his books at a garage sale, a fairly complete set, and can’t seem to get past the third grade mentality of liking them.
[10] ALChemy › Dovina 17-May-06/7:09 AM Reply
You'd think that opening you left for yourself would have brought Zodiac out of hiding almost instantly.
[n/a] Dovina › ALChemy 17-May-06/10:26 AM Reply
If he agrees that I have a third grade mentality, it would probably be the greatest compliment he has given me.
[8] richa 17-May-06/2:33 PM Reply
'She knew her life’s pattern; her ethics were set'. Don't like this. It is just stating the plot. Show don't tell.
[4] Edna Sweetlove 19-May-06/4:52 AM Reply
Groveling? Groveling? You mean, to rhyme with "revealing" and "ceiling" ?
[5] Caducus 19-May-06/5:39 AM Reply
Sorry this one made me dizzy and like my boss needs a makeover.

Your problem here i think is the story overbears th epoetry within it.

C'mon Dovina love gimmee a Dovina special.
[n/a] Dovina › Caducus 19-May-06/4:58 PM Reply
Keep the men in your life dizzy, but never give ‘em anything special. That’s what my grandmother used to say.
[2] Stephen Robins 19-May-06/8:03 AM Reply
like a germ laden hanky deposited NEXT to a bin.
[n/a] Dovina › Stephen Robins 19-May-06/4:58 PM Reply
Thank you for pointing out that I deposited this lovely crochet-edged hankie next to the bin where it can be seen by passers-by, not only for its crafted beauty, but also for its earthy richness. To have said that I put it IN the bin could only have meant that I was ashamed of it, and that was certainly not your intent. Oh, I am so flattered that you understood this delicate rendering and thought enough of it to apply this fine metaphor.
[7] Sunny 20-May-06/1:55 PM Reply

I found this to be a very clean piece, although I am one of 'those' who doesn't really care for caps w/ each new line, but I can still look past this of course. I like circles. I like circular stories...so is life, isn't it?!

My own personal notes:
-L2S1: I think starting out the line with "For" is unnecessary & reads awkwardly
-The play again & again of humility such as bringing up the van they were in repeatedly & such word usage as "...the best little farm..." is very nicely played on
-This is a "growth poem" per say - I liked that
-Didn't like how the "forest HEATED her home"...just didn't click w/ me
-Don't feel SHE needs to be screamed out in all caps. I don't feel that way in any instance in poetry however, just me.
-Good ending. Sharp & unpredictable, reading line by line

~Sunny
[9] elderking 21-May-06/7:24 AM Reply
Dovina, This was an unexpected journey down memory lane. Very sweet and nostalgic. It touched me enough to give my Dad a call! Good work.