Help | About | Suggestions | Alms | Chat [0] | Users [0] | Log In | Join
 Search:
Poem: Submit | Random | Best | Worst | Recent | Comments   

Death Of A Rose (New draft) (Haiku) by Mr Pig
Petals fall like tears, The arid earth is washed In beautiful blood.

Down the ladder: Elegy

You must be logged in to leave comments. Vote:

Votes: (green: user, blue: anonymous)
 GraphVotes
10  .. 40
.. 31
.. 20
.. 11
.. 01
.. 00
.. 00
.. 01
.. 00
.. 10
.. 23

Arithmetic Mean: 5.8
Weighted score: 5.762059
Overall Rank: 1782
Posted: April 26, 2003 1:55 AM PDT; Last modified: April 27, 2003 4:26 AM PDT
View voting details
Comments:
[10] Ranger @ 212.140.114.61 | 26-Apr-03/4:04 AM | Reply
Sorry, my friend Mr Pig dude, but this is two syllables over for a haiku. Perhaps if you changed 'lacerated' to 'ripped', or even 'torn' (to go with 'thorns' albeit badly) then you will be 1 syllable under the limit (this is beginning to sound like we're talking about drink-driving now). Then I reckon you could turn the first 'like' into 'as if' which would take you to exactly 17 and would eliminate the repetition of like. That's my opinion anyway.
Aside from that, I enjoyed this haiku, the laceration and bleeding was well done, and you got the element of sadness spot on. Good stuff. I won't vote now, I will let you digest my thoughts and decide what you want to do and hopefully later I'll come back and take another look.
[n/a] Mr Pig @ 195.92.168.163 > Ranger | 27-Apr-03/4:26 AM | Reply
I think this is 17 syl please clarify kind sir.
[10] Ranger @ 213.120.56.37 > Mr Pig | 27-Apr-03/6:42 AM | Reply
I think this version is perfect. The imagery is all there (assuming 'imagery' is a word and not something I've just made up).
Having taken another look, you have one more syllable to play with (I probably sound really pedantic here; I'm sorry because I don't mean to).
Petals fall like torn tears
Dark arid earth is washed
In beautiful blood

Your one is equally good, probably better.

Can I make a request? Do a collection of haikus telling some sort of story, or something like that. You are the three-line master as far as I'm concerned.
10
[n/a] Mr Pig @ 195.92.168.166 > Ranger | 28-Apr-03/1:20 PM | Reply
Thank you for your informative comment, charmed I'm sure.
[10] Ranger @ 213.120.56.45 > Mr Pig | 29-Apr-03/10:45 AM | Reply
My pleasure.
[9] INTRANSIT @ 152.163.188.72 | 26-Apr-03/5:47 AM | Reply
I'm no haiku expert but I find this quite beautiful. My mind snags the petals on the thorns and they never reach ground though.
[8] richa @ 195.92.168.173 | 26-Apr-03/10:12 AM | Reply
yes I would change lacerated too, it just seems out of place.
Overall though very delicate and in the spirit of haiku(if not quite the syllable count)
[8] BleedingRose @ 4.63.225.58 | 26-Apr-03/6:54 PM | Reply
I love it! i think ill jot this one down in my little book. Though i cant give it a perfect score because of the whole haiku problem which others have already pointed out . but id love to see a revised edition!
[n/a] -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. @ 131.111.8.98 > BleedingRose | 26-Apr-03/7:25 PM | Reply
spazmo
[8] BleedingRose @ 4.63.225.58 > -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. | 26-Apr-03/9:08 PM | Reply
sounds like a really hyper sesame street character...
[n/a] -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. @ 131.111.8.98 | 27-Apr-03/3:20 AM | Reply
Great use of the word "Like". Sometimes a metaphor can be too strong, can't it? May I suggest:

DETH-ROSE

Petals fall like bricks;
piloted by vicious prawnes,
they land on my face.
[10] Ranger @ 213.120.56.37 > -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. | 27-Apr-03/6:43 AM | Reply
I see serious potential here...
Damn those prawnes. Damn them!
[n/a] -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. @ 131.111.8.101 > Ranger | 27-Apr-03/9:07 AM | Reply
You can't blame the prawnes. They're just doing what they've been trained to do. If you had to spend six years in a Viet-Cong tiger cage, feasting on twigs and very small bits of gravel, then you'd probably be flying er... petals... straight into people's faces, too.
[n/a] <{Baba^Yaga}> @ 24.126.113.154 > -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. | 27-Apr-03/5:17 PM | Reply
I saw a prawn last night eating snake skin, python to be exact. I find prawns to be... Well, even fouler then deer ticks and compulsively grooming snow monkeys. Now parrots, on the other hand, are more of a learnded and schoolasticaly appropriated pet for a genitalman. Prawns are however great eating with 'a butter' and collard greens washed down with an icy colded schlitz brewskydew in August as long as you have lots of thin and tan swim suit wearing peers smiling about pointless shit like sex and grades hanging around and blowing smoke up your arse. huh?
[10] Ranger @ 213.120.56.45 > -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. | 29-Apr-03/10:44 AM | Reply
Ah, I do apologise...I stand corrected.
I believe that I must go and revise my crustacean history.
Thank you my good Sir.
Good Evening.
[n/a] Blindproject217 @ 68.38.194.4 > Ranger | 27-Apr-03/2:46 PM | Reply
Hey man, dont mess with the prawnes!
[n/a] <{Baba^Yaga}> @ 24.126.113.154 > Blindproject217 | 27-Apr-03/5:18 PM | Reply
Shut up.
[8] richa @ 195.92.168.170 | 27-Apr-03/5:01 AM | Reply
Interesting, you seem to have changed the tone of the poem wildly by changing one word

very charming
[9] INTRANSIT @ 64.12.96.46 | 27-Apr-03/5:45 AM | Reply
I like this better.
[10] maffy @ 195.92.168.165 | 27-Apr-03/6:25 AM | Reply
Simplistic, beautiful and ironic - I loved it. 10
[7] horus8 @ 24.126.113.154 | 27-Apr-03/1:22 PM | Reply
Petals crack, dust dry.
An arid earth wets its lips.
Beautiful last time.
[n/a] Mr Pig @ 195.92.168.166 > horus8 | 28-Apr-03/1:21 PM | Reply
Eminence achieved in your comment
[n/a] Blindproject217 @ 68.38.194.4 | 27-Apr-03/2:51 PM | Reply
Petals from zuzu's hand
its not such a wonderful life
Curse the prawnes that did this

Now THAT is a beatiful haiku, even though its 2 slys over the seventeen limit, but hey if Mr pig can get away with it so can I.
[n/a] JakeBike @ 167.206.181.179 | 28-Apr-03/1:26 PM | Reply
how about velevted blood?
instead of beautiful?
[9] deleted user @ 63.230.192.38 | 4-Sep-03/6:38 PM | Reply
This is stunning work! You are very gifted.
[8] sliver @ 65.178.192.197 | 5-Sep-03/8:27 PM | Reply
I like it, I see now why it rates so high. kudos
307 view(s)




Track and Plan your submissions ; Read some Comics ; Get Paid for your Poetry
PoemRanker Copyright © 2001 - 2024 - kaolin fire - All Rights Reserved
All poems Copyright © their respective authors
An internet tradition since June 9, 2001