CommentsComments 15041–15060 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

ALChemy on Ruins by Caducus 25 Oct 2005, 7:36 AM
Put "I'm" at the beginning of "sculptured by architects". You've got punctuation problems in the first stanza. Some nice sentiment though.
Dovina on dialect by skaskowski 25 Oct 2005, 7:33 AM
Like a bad dream. But the next to last verse suggests God. That's a good verse.
ALChemy replying on Ruins by Caducus 25 Oct 2005, 7:32 AM
Unless he's refering to himself being sculptured by the architects but that's quite a stretch. At least help us out with an "I'm" at the begining Caducus.
Dovina on i hung that page to dry by FreeFormFixation 25 Oct 2005, 7:28 AM
speak for the spoken silence - maybe leave out spoken. fall to the floor as ash - maybe leave out fall.
Dovina on hoppy by calliope 25 Oct 2005, 7:24 AM
Yes. Eat, drink and be merry, make love, for tomorrow you die. There, is hope.
ALChemy on Questions by TLRufener 25 Oct 2005, 7:15 AM
Answer: No and nothing.
Dovina replying on Incommunicado blues (fixed, except for Dovina) by zodiac 25 Oct 2005, 7:13 AM
Please retract that! The planet cannot handle such evolutionary goals.
Dovina replying on Eternity by Dovina 25 Oct 2005, 7:08 AM
Yes I will say “But that’s the whole point.” See my comment to Alchemy. If you say “Exactly,” you are simply disagreeing with the Christian position that “To die is gain.” It’s alright to disagree, but please try to understand this dying woman’s position.
Dovina replying on Eternity by Dovina 25 Oct 2005, 7:08 AM
I did write in MS Word, but I wanted the capitals as a kind of Biblical parallel. "But the opposite is true" refers to the line directly above it. You say BOO because it seems contradictory. But for a Christian, a dying body is good because it brings her nearer to her God. “To be absent from the body is to be present with God.”
ALChemy on fox and hounds by nentwined 25 Oct 2005, 7:00 AM
Why baboon? I assume it means the fox. besides the dogs anger, who else has anger and why? The one anger actually seems to imply one out of two or more. "an anger" would be clearer. This would make a great introduction to something. Love the suggestion of rhyme in this poem.
ALChemy on Eternity by Dovina 25 Oct 2005, 6:29 AM
If "But the opposite is true" refers to "It’s location location location" then bravo. If it refers to "Her condition’s going down" than BOO! It's the meat of a contradiction sandwich because you follow with -"Strength and vigor exhausted". I know you're taking what the doctors are saying out of context but it's a bit confusing. Did you write this in MS Word because all the first letters in each line are capitalized. Interesting point of view. Optimistic, no sense of dread what-so-ever.
PS: Great critique and suggestions on my latest poem. I was on vacation, as you were from my constant debating.
Ironic that this is the one people seem to get. Also ironic that you recently scolded me for having strung together phrases. Love the toothless men with knives line. A little Freudian Psycho-babble for ya. Religion is in a warm vagina. You're not gonna find it in the chosen land. Atheism is in a masturbater's fist. Your religion's in alaska but your pride is in your hand. ALChemy psycho-babble: Get your ass to Alaska pronto lest thou fall amongst ye dumb morons. -10-
ALChemy replying on There is a journey tree by ALChemy 25 Oct 2005, 4:37 AM
To me it represents one thing but it's kinda like saying God and expecting everyone to think of the same god your thinking of. I think it's lack of elaboration is due more to my laziness then sloppiness.
ALChemy replying on There is a journey tree by ALChemy 25 Oct 2005, 4:31 AM
Thanks LadyPoet The bird thing was kinda an experiment. It in one way criticizes the pre-concieved religious symbolism of the tree and in that way contradicts it. I thought it would be appropriate to have the bird line interupt the poem but I conceed it does throw the reader off a bit. I looked up booth brink and amidst and there doesn't seem to be a problem. Brink: The upper edge of a steep or vertical slope. The verge. Amidst:(or Amid) Surrounded by; in the middle of. I must be missing something obvious I guess. Good suggestions. I hope there's a tree too. Lord knows I'll probably need it. Sorry about the punctuation I must have had something against periods that day.
ALChemy replying on There is a journey tree by ALChemy 25 Oct 2005, 4:06 AM
That's some of the best criticism I've read. Actually it's from a regular prose story. It's just a poem one of the characters recalls after they actually find the tree. Story poems are incredibly hard to do well. Usually either the story or the poetry is hindered because of it. I admit the poems got alot of flaws. I really like it mostly for its sound. I think there's a sweet spot that floats between free-verse and conventional verse but it's hard as hell to hit. I looked up "amidst" and the first definition I got was "in the middle of" so maybe its an outdated usage of the word I don't know. Great suggestion for a change though. Pigeons and doves: And yet people treat them so differently. Sometimes when I write or draw I start with an image and just let the poem evolve piece by piece never exactly sure where it will go. This usually ends with a product that's high in sound, low in logic. Then I edit. I wonder if Wordsworth and Coleridge approached writing that way. Most of the story (that the poem is in) takes place in a dream world.(I know cliches abound) But the story was meant to be sort of a parable of the Gospels. It was my attempt to put the reader into the mind and perspective of a messiah in a way they could imagine and relate to. Not a good subject to write a first book on. I'd be a hypocrite to criticize your spelling. Although it's fun to point out because it happens so rarely with you. Sorry it took so long to reply. I was on vacation.
zodiac on hoppy by calliope 25 Oct 2005, 3:07 AM
God bless thy poor bald pate. God bless. thy hollow winking eyes God bless thy shriveld beard. God. bless. thy many wrinkled forehead Thou hast no teeth old man & thus I kiss thy sleek bald head Heva come kiss his bald head for he will not hurt us Heva -Blake, Tiriel
zodiac on i hung that page to dry by FreeFormFixation 25 Oct 2005, 3:03 AM
Are you painting a photograph? Touching-up?
zodiac on dialect by skaskowski 25 Oct 2005, 3:02 AM
A: Negro.
Way to fix the title. Now what's with all the randomly capitalized words?