poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 12101–12120 back. Include replies to comments

Ever the asshole...
some deleted user on honey bee by ThePariahDog 26 May 2005, 4:42 AM
'Mellifluent' sets off the rhythm of the poem, but right after that rhythm isn't maintained... I can't place the 'replaced' bit.
some deleted user on Kiteflying by april fool 26 May 2005, 4:44 AM
This reads like a commercial rhyme from the 1950's...
some deleted user on Star Studded Supermarket by [mojo] 26 May 2005, 4:49 AM
It's almost funny. You should have quit after stanza four. Rewrite this. In satirical proza.
INTRANSIT on some deleted poem 26 May 2005, 6:21 AM
Tempt eve with a better ace? Cheap. The end made my face go red.
INTRANSIT on Star Studded Supermarket by [mojo] 26 May 2005, 6:30 AM
This is funny and worth the effort to iron out. My first thoughts are: lose stanza 10, the clouds. and go with the four line stanzas. Really! Do this ! Or else!
i get it.
INTRANSIT on Yesterdays testament by Caducus 26 May 2005, 7:55 AM
You read Plath? holy cow. I'd better give her a once over at least.
mmmph...
wilco on Never Ending Cycle by ingwa 25 May 2005, 6:23 PM
Some interfsting images here, but Rockmage is right above: They don't hang together well.
wilco on some deleted poem 25 May 2005, 6:24 PM
Nice ending, but sorry to say, the rest is not....ummm great....
wilco on Semite to Semite by PodPoet 25 May 2005, 6:26 PM
The indentations are not needed. Also for someone who wants to kill the cliche, there's a lot of it here...maybe that's the point.
wilco on Watcher by windyone 25 May 2005, 6:31 PM
What's the point to all of this? Could've been a lot shorter saying: Sad Girl No Love Pain She's changed.
some deleted user on Watcher by windyone 25 May 2005, 6:38 PM
Agree with Rockmage. But I also object to the treatment of the story. The pain, the pain. Could be the base for a poem that does not need the word 'pain'... << her lover can't, or won't love her >> Perhaps she's unbearable ugly? Frigid? He found out she wasn't the rich bitch he thought she was? You don't show anything. She, watching him leave the house with a stiff back, clenched fists, for instance. An empty stare. An upturned dinnerplate on the tabel. There are so many ways to visualize relational pain. The best lines are the last one and 'It's all the same to her', but they become statements that call for an explanation. They are too detached from what it is all about.
xxx on some deleted poem 25 May 2005, 6:45 PM
This is really just a very poor sort of remake of a religious text. I can be considered cute. It is not good.
some deleted user on some deleted poem 25 May 2005, 6:47 PM
Viewing this as a text for a rocksong? Was it written to music, and thus compromised, or was the music folded around the existing text? It has its moments, except for the first five lines; nonsense.
Dovina on Horatio by april fool 26 May 2005, 8:30 AM
The third verse seems weak compared to the rest.
Dovina on Forbidden by Caducus 26 May 2005, 8:33 AM
If you're using punctuation, why not in widow's?
Dan garcia-Black on Horatio by april fool 26 May 2005, 8:15 AM
In Los Angeles, Whore-ratio to Johns is an important factor in discerning the economic health of business around bridges and industrial parks. Right now the Horatio is in custody pending arraignment for solicitation of a police officer for an unnatural act (he asked LAPD to arrest a black guy without beating the shit out of him) I don't think Horatio will make it "virgin intactae" for his court date.
You have 9 open and 8 closed. Remove the first open in the second line. If you'd used my method this would not have happened.