edpeterson
replying on Fastso by Dovina
8 Mar 2005, 10:02 AM
rite!
yah. this gives me a chubby.
Thatâs great that he was able to read it. Did he get all of the words, even metamorphose? Even if he didnât, but figured out the way it works, thatâs good for a fifth grader. Maybe they have an easier time of bringing order to chaos than we do.
I was hoping the reader would infer something about the woman from the last line - that being unliked herself, she understands the feelings this boy must have. Otherwise the poem would be merely a description of the fat boy, and the woman just an observer. You seem to see this. To say more about her would detract, I think, from the blunt focus on the fat boy, and overcomplicate the story.
Stephen Robins
on Fat girls Who Wear Short Skirts During Winter Quarter by DurtKL
8 Mar 2005, 5:23 AM
have you ever been to Cardiff? - 10 -
Poor people are more likely to be fat, diseased, alcoholic, smokers, drug addicts, criminals, victims of crime, depressed, schizophrenic. You call this an irrelevance and then criticise an gentleman's portrayal of poorness as a bit smelly. Let me ask you this. Is it better to sweep clean the pavement because it is smelly or to not sweep clean the smelly pavement because you believe it to be jolly?
Nicely put together D.
Rod, I've told you before -- please stay off my computer. Thanks.
Well done, old chap! 10.
clear and clever imagery. the last two stanzas, however, are tritely phrased in comparison with the rest. also, since we don't know anything about the speaker, that she sympathizes with our corpulent friend has no effect on the reader beyond allowing him or her to make an inference about the speaker's character. otherwise, an enjoyable poem.
Jebus, this is why I say you are my best friend. . .New one, you should've read me it first, Eli!!! >.< I love it. You know why, too.
Dude, Eli, who told u that?! I don't remember ME saying that. . .Was it Sergio?! Anyway, LOVELY! MY VERY FIRST FAV!