poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 11141–11160 back. Include replies to comments

Dovina on Lover by Dental Panic 8 Jul 2005, 10:26 AM
Why continue in verse 3 with the bus? It seems to cloud a good start. And the break between verses 1 and 2 seems wrong.
Dovina on A World At War by Damien 8 Jul 2005, 10:30 AM
Too many words, and not carefully chosen. "safely wallowing in safety" for example.
Dovina on some deleted poem 8 Jul 2005, 9:01 PM
We're terrible that way. Monstrous.
Dovina on JUST A FEW by rbooey 8 Jul 2005, 9:05 PM
I thought I knew who MUM was until the end. Weird.
david on some deleted poem 8 Jul 2005, 9:08 PM
It's as though you've been watching me eating pistachios late at night, weeping for the ones I can't open.
Dovina on some deleted poem 8 Jul 2005, 10:37 AM
At least I know that all these recent poems about the London attacks are recent poems. I think it's best to post our most recent stuff, rather than dragging up old poems as some do. It keeps the comments current and alive. This good up through "courageous fellows." Then "covet thy Moslem" doesn't make much sense, nor does "is this the Kuran?" And the last verse seems like an angry rant without much real content.
It’s strange but I feel guilty. The kind of guilt one might feel after reading someone’s diary. This work is so personal, so strong. It should be rolled up and tied up with the small red string that she left for you in that box. There’s more to say but I can’t. Thank You.
Dovina on some deleted poem 8 Jul 2005, 3:54 PM
You heard this, right? It came as a forewarded email.
Dovina on Lover by Dental Panic 9 Jul 2005, 4:36 PM
It's better now, clearer. Still, the timing of your posting and the tube, river, therain and all implies the London bombings. Then why is it called Lover? And why is it bad luck that he was not on the train that was bombed? Maybe he avoided the train disaster only to get on the bus to be blown up. It's not clear.
Dental Panic on Endurance by Dovina 9 Jul 2005, 4:40 PM
I'm in the dark. It seems a very private thing to me, with strange imagery.
ALChemy on JUST A FEW by rbooey 9 Jul 2005, 8:27 AM
I could give my opinion but the only opinion that matters about this poem is your MUM's. And if somewhere out there she say's it's GREAT then who the hell am I to argue.
ALChemy on Almost Persuaded by Dovina 9 Jul 2005, 9:11 AM
If you make a vague poem people will get different meanings from it. I like that I can give this my own meaning. I like the switch from possitivity to negetivity at the end. But "ambling"? Although with alot of thought I see how you might be going for the Gen. Patton type image calmly surveying the battlefield. I think it just tends to come across as a fancy word for walking for most. Try some other words. The second verse just needs a little tweeking. It's pretty good Though.
edpeterson on Lover by Dental Panic 9 Jul 2005, 8:18 PM
I think this is excellent
Bankrupt_Word_Clerk on Slice Open My Body by TLRufener 9 Jul 2005, 11:25 PM
I would change the first two lines a little. I'd write something like "I'd tell you to slice open my body and tear out my heart, but you already have."
zodiac on Endurance by Dovina 10 Jul 2005, 10:27 PM
Not good.
zodiac on some deleted poem 10 Jul 2005, 10:48 PM
The best Islam poem on poemranker today. Did you know Sahib comes from the root word "to pull"? No? Ace!
zodiac on London Calling by Bluemonkey 10 Jul 2005, 10:51 PM
"bearded attempts" is great.
zodiac on Almost Persuaded by Dovina 10 Jul 2005, 10:03 PM
I don't get the connection between "world spinning" (positive) and "uniformity" (negative). Just a nitpick. You probably meant "spinning" like 'dizzy and disoriented'. That's fine, it's just not the first meaning I got. Q: Does it take more work to keep an already-spinning world spinning or to stop it? Please include any relevant charts and diagrams in your answer. PS-Ace rhyme. Really.
LilMsLadyPoet on Apathy by nentwined 11 Jul 2005, 7:23 AM
ooo...I like this...there are a few places where the choice to break word flow/sentence/thought, within the lines, is strange to me... "Trust in one's own self opens eyes and grants power" About: "there's momentous" , think an "a" in there would be nice; especially since you use "on a flower". I admit that it is hard to use puncuation correctly, at times, especially with poems like this, that are freeflowing thoughts that lead into one another, often disconnected, but connected, depending on how it is read...that said, I believe the rule is: If you use puncuation, (You do) then use it throughout the piece, (You don't; I see commas, but no periods. I see sentences, I think, but it is not clear where they start and end. If this is intentional, then I would remove all punctuation, and let the reader flit along or float along unaided by punctuation. If you want things to read as a definitly defined thought or sentence, then use punctuation. The first three lines are exceptional!! The next three awesome, also! I love your word choices... >"gnoshing green leaves". Do some editing and I would be tempted to give it a 9...*smile*, as I don't give 10's.