poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 6841–6860 back. Include replies to comments

x0lovelylarnx0 on The Tuesday Dogs by Caducus 18 Mar 2006, 1:07 PM
How sad.
Ranger on Likeness by MacFrantic 18 Mar 2006, 5:06 AM
'Tis the season to be jolly...oh, wait. Good ending!
ALChemy on Mid-July by Ranger 18 Mar 2006, 7:12 AM
Poe often rewrote his poems even after publishing them. He was THAT anal about them. Good stuff but these are the kind of poems you'll keep messing with.
MacFrantic on The Peccadillary by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 18 Mar 2006, 12:12 AM
Sweet lord 'twas remarkable. I do hope you do more. Particularly funny: "To go on a bender with communion wine." and "To address a Knight of the Realm as a 'Mr'." *10*
ecargo on The Peccadillary by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 18 Mar 2006, 10:42 AM
It's all got me feeling quite delirious. "To deliberately pluralise 'sheep' as 'sheeps'" is no mere peccadillo, though--it's an abomination! I'd love to see your take on an abcedarium.
Ranger on Majdanek by Niphredil 18 Mar 2006, 2:25 PM
Powerful; the imagery in the last 5 lines could possibly be brought out a bit more. Not sure about 'timber creaked with evil'...it doesn't really creak with evil - timber creaked despairingly, maybe?
Ranger on Black Belt by etherealmaiden 18 Mar 2006, 2:21 PM
This is cool, nicely concise - fast as though struggling for breath (due to the belt being too tight). There are a couple of places where I'd change word choices purely for rhythmical reasons - 'couples all around' I'd change to 'couples around', 'I must lose weight' would work better as 'I have to lose weight', but to be fair these are just small issues. Overall, not bad!
Niphredil on Mid-July by Ranger 18 Mar 2006, 9:31 AM
Well, I *was* going to begin this post with "Quoth the Raven: nevermore", but after reading other comments it seems a bit redundant... The poem is terrific! A little polish, perhaps, would be in order to earn this a round 10, but as it is, the flow is excellent (and I have no doubt that was tough...) , it reads well and is quite beautiful to top it off. Little critique with "Cerberus, her eyes resembled". The 'her' is unclear. If you're talking about your daughter (as it seems, since you continue to use 'her' in following sentences) then 'steel and gore' sounds way out of place. If you're talking about Cerberus, well... it ain't female! "Must she lay in darkness fading" - change 'lay' to 'lie'. I also think that 'reprise' in line 7 is misplaced. It means the recurrence or renewal of an action, not an amnesty or pardon. I think. That aside, it really is a lovely piece of work.
Ranger on The Horror The Horror by Nicholas Jones 17 Mar 2006, 10:29 AM
Stanza 9 - so very true. Well, I've never joined a socialist party, but still I hear what you're saying. Having missed the news yesterday I didn't get the story of those drug tests that went wrong...but that sounded like a 'The horror! The horror!' moment...
ecargo on The Horror The Horror by Nicholas Jones 17 Mar 2006, 1:30 PM
"Mistah Kurtz—he dead. A penny for the Old Guy" Lots to work with here--many good lines and thoughts. Leans a little to the side of polemic though.
Ranger on The Peccadillary by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 17 Mar 2006, 2:21 PM
HA! Supreme, once again. You prove once again to be the poemranker Master of Rhyme (P.I.) Give me one good reason why I shouldn't blabber childish adulation all over your poetry! -9- 'To address a Knight of the Realm as a "Mr."' - unforgivable.
Ranger on Looking Back by x0lovelylarnx0 17 Mar 2006, 3:49 PM
Hmm...potential, but it really needs changes (in my opinion). The ideas are nice but the word choices don't do it any sort of justice. Try using fewer pronouns (this is a pretty universal rule), particularly if you want the reader to 'relate'. Also...think about rewriting this in the 3rd person - it gives you a lot more scope to be creative, to invent imagery and use metaphorical language. Which will earn you bonus points on here, trust me. Keep working at it.
Dovina on Mid-July by Ranger 17 Mar 2006, 4:15 PM
An old-time Poe sadness, and just as good as Poe.
MacFrantic on Looking Back by x0lovelylarnx0 18 Mar 2006, 12:08 AM
Good "conversational" piece, but a bit lacking as a poem. Was "elementry" intentional? Please say it was. *6*
Ranger on My God by ElmoBeavisButthead 18 Mar 2006, 6:13 AM
Hmm, I never was one for existential thought, but it's not a bad poem. I like the fact that it's concise, in a way, but then I'd also like to see it more...substantial, if you see what I mean. The first line sets a good tone for the poem; but as far as imagery goes you don't capitalise on the potential. I don't know, maybe you don't want visuals in here...that's fair enough, but my preference is to see something tactile - particularly something creative, something vivid and imaginative. Having said that, however, what you do say is said well...you don't give in to the 'preach-y' nature that often accompanies poems such as this. Have a look round various poems on here - see what you think to the styles kicking about. 7 from me - with any luck you'll get some useful advice from the better poets here.
ElmoBeavisButthead on My God by ElmoBeavisButthead 18 Mar 2006, 6:31 AM
It's just I don't think it would sound right with "I" in there..
MacFrantic on Mid-July by Ranger 18 Mar 2006, 12:04 AM
Pretty good, true to form. A bit of an awkward read, something about the rhythm. Still enjoyable. *8*
Niphredil on some deleted poem 18 Mar 2006, 9:51 AM
Could someone please enlighten me? afraid I don't get it.
Niphredil on Indiscrete by ecargo 18 Mar 2006, 9:47 AM
I wonder if your title is a spelling error of 'indiscreet'? Because if so, it sounds like you're giving a terrific description of waking up in a strange apartment, after a one-night stand. (jeez, I wonder if I'm waay off the mark here). Assuming it ain't a mistake, the title means, loosely, 'continuous' or 'not individually distinct', and I'm having trouble associating it with the rest of the poem which is very individualistic. I actually like this meaning better; it's unconventional and interesting, and I might just consider blatant plagiarism... *blushes*