poemranker ::20 most recent comments by Geschäftsreise (41-60) and replies

Comments byGeschäftsreise, 41–60 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

The tongues are indispensible. Otherwise it's 'cheese' without the 'tom'.
replying on sitting at the cliff's edge by nentwined 15 Sep 2003, 4:48 PM
(nod) By the way, I've been thinking about this last stanza and the more I say it in my mind the more I love it:

the interjection of humour about getting near the edge of the cliff subtly adds a warmth and depth to the whole scene that is indispensible:

It is done in such a coy way (inserted into a solemn repetition) that is almost strong enough to oppose your claim of longing - leaving the reader with a sense of 'grinning nostalgia' for lack of a better term.
on playing the scratching game by nentwined 15 Sep 2003, 11:02 AM
But if I scratch off too many I won't win the free medium drink!
replying on sitting at the cliff's edge by nentwined 15 Sep 2003, 8:44 AM
5/6 of this is (obviously) yours
1/6 had not been put into words before
on sitting at the cliff's edge by nentwined 15 Sep 2003, 12:04 AM
Normally I avoid sentimentality (especially in poetry), but this poem must be good because it reminded me of the once upon a time upon a cliff's edge (I hope you will not be insulted by a crude harmony to your melody):

sitting at the cliff's edge,
I muse
that there is where I went
with my lover
when lover she was

and we could imagine ourselves alone
but for a horse
A fitting chaperone
for this lonely castle wall.

and alone we'd be together and together
the world would fade
and all that would be was the two of us
and the rocks and the sea and a hundred gulls
mocking our affection

and now the rocks and sea and windy gusts
only in my thoughts remain
and dying these dreams
(or close enough)
but one remains
(or close enough)
to be near that edge,
(or close enough)
I long for you and Scotland.



replying on These are not just words by impert&ent 14 Sep 2003, 11:18 PM
I woose more weaders that way...
on These are not just words by impert&ent 14 Sep 2003, 10:29 PM
I couldn't agree more with your sentiment (my babelfish poetry may entertain you if you feel this way).

However if I were to focus on your phrasing I would say that words can and are meant to persuade as well as convey. Otherwise what are salesmen?

But the last stanza is gorgeous, and even more than that - it is a passionate truth.
You must download japanese language support for your browser in order to see the characters.
replying on Plastic is Forever by http://mulberryfairy 13 Sep 2003, 11:05 PM
Please forgive me I am new. You must be the same person as this supremebeaner, supremedreamer, and The third isis, as well as being baphomet. Why do you critique poetry without critiquing it?
on Plastic is Forever by http://mulberryfairy 13 Sep 2003, 11:02 PM
This poem has an interesting tension between 1.) being marketed 'fun' (plus the narrator's friend's ability to enjoy it in spite of the commercialization) and 2.) Your apparent objective indifference to (or even slight critique of) the whole thing.
Basta con la mota. Lea por favor el poema antes de darle un número.
on Giger cider by grendal 12 Sep 2003, 9:43 AM
i enjoyed this (the arbitrary list of ingredients and the final justification could be reworked in order to make this a serious poem)
on canto di desiderio by Bill Z Bub 7 Sep 2003, 9:59 PM
Credo che dovrte rimuovere la traduzione. Coloro che non capisce che l'italiano sarà costretto per soffrire la nebbia di babelfish e coloro che capisce l'italiano riterranno lo scopo progettato.

Forse è migliore senza la traduzione (ma molto elegante)
Eu sei exatamente a parcela do livro que você está consultando a...
exactement. parlé avec l'esprit vrai.
replying on Babelfish Poetry (III): Segen (Deutsch) by Geschäftsreise 7 Sep 2003, 5:10 PM
und Ihre Mutter nicht?
replying on Babelfish Poetry (III): Segen (Deutsch) by Geschäftsreise 7 Sep 2003, 5:05 PM
Ich bin nicht skrupulös, irgendwelche dieser Umhänge zu behaupten.
replying on (untitled) by http://bandgeek 7 Sep 2003, 12:14 PM
Ich spreche keine Sprache. Es gibt nur Gedanken. Der ist mein Punkt - es gibt keine Untreue in meinen Gedanken und folglich in meiner Sprache.
purtugese