poemranker ::The Unknown Soldier by abcmonkey78

DetailsThe poem, its numbers, and the conversation.

Other № 95142

The Unknown Soldier

Member since 2004 · Posted 26 Mar 2004 · 3 comments

We just finished studying WWI in Modern World History, so I wrote this: Upon the plains of sorrow, upon the worthless land, I am the unknown soldier, and that is where I stand; There's ceaseless noise around me, that carries with it death, And all the more I think about it, fear disgruntles breath; The iron hawks above me, will cry their deathly call, 'Till one will wound the other, and the wounded one will fall; The leaded hornets pass me, whos sting is so severe That if we had collided, I would not be leaving here; Behind me, past the trenches, five miles from this hell, Are fields full of crosses, where many men rest well; But I will progress further: my life that cannot be, For my generation's boat is still a ship thats lost at sea.

Rate it

0 is the worst, 10 the best. Pick a number, add a comment if you like, then send it. Keys: 0–9 pick, Enter sends.

mean 6.20 weighted 5.14 rank 5395 views 205 View voting details →

5 votes so far. Yours would make 6.5 votes so far

A favorite of DarkThirteens.

3 comments

[7] Shuushin 26-Mar-04/7:52 AM Reply
not bad, monkey. the longer lines help the AA BB rhymes which can easily be tiresome.

Maybe you can do something with this line
"And all the more I think about it, fear disgruntles breath"

and the last couplet, too. What's there is an example of a mixed metaphor - you have all this infantry imagery, then in comes the navy. Know what I mean? Don't run out of steam at the end!!

lastly, I won't second guess all your semicolons, since I'm pretty lenient with them, but I raised an eyebrow at a few.
[n/a] abcmonkey78 › Shuushin 12-Jun-04/10:57 AM Reply
Maybe this for that line?
"And all the more I contemplate it, fear disgruntles death."

And possibly this to replace the "navy" like ending, which I understand could be awkward.

"For my generation's limb shall be the one torn off the tree."

And finally, yes, I have very little education as to where semicolons should be placed. So if you raise an eyebrow to any, it's got a high possibility of being misplaced.
[8] Ranger 18-Apr-06/1:26 AM Reply
Firstly, 'The Unknown Soldier' is the title of a Doors song; you might consider changing it in case people make assumptions.
There are some good lines and metaphors here - 'iron hawks', 'leaded hornets' (should probably be 'leaden hornets'), and the last line is pretty smart too.
There are a few too many commas and semicolons (as has been noted already), and a couple of grammatical crits, but on the whole it's a decent poem.