poemranker ::Desperate Season by Sisterwolf

DetailsThe poem, its numbers, and the conversation.

Free verse № 136041

Desperate Season

Member since 2005 · Posted 30 Dec 2005 · 8 comments

Now is the chilled and stark mien of winter’s death, running its fingers through its frozen hair Dark, withdrawn and without joy. Earth is no closer to death than this, as the planet blindly feels for light. Ancient man watched the horizon, seeking one stray thread of sun, something to reassure his terror. Dispirited cattle crunch through ice, their hooves immersed in half-frozen water, mud, sludge. Lowing for their warm barn they protest their exposure to the field. Between the dawn and darkening there are so few hours of living. Beds are singing, covers hum of warmth and desperate escape. Will no crocus peek its head out of the soaked and sodden earth so drear. Will the ice never break and let spring flow out into the land in salvation. Then in summer’s rude glaze of heat, the heart cannot help but remember that abysmal time with fondness, as if when next it came it would be embraced.

Rate it

0 is the worst, 10 the best. Pick a number, add a comment if you like, then send it. Keys: 0–9 pick, Enter sends.

mean 6.25 weighted 5.34 rank 3455 views 245 View voting details →

8 votes so far. Yours would make 9.8 votes so far

8 comments

[7] Dovina 30-Dec-05/5:02 PM Reply
I felt good about this, felt their dismay, until the last verse. Then summer's suddenness seemed as if it should remain in their minds as a hope, not a reality quite yet.

I also think "Dark, withdrawn and without joy" is too strong for an ordinary winter. And "terror" also seems demeaning of people who know the seasons.
[n/a] Sisterwolf › Dovina 30-Dec-05/5:16 PM Reply
I use a poetic device, juxtaposition - to jar the reader.
Plus, my justification is that I don't use it present tense,
but future perfect.

For me, winter is dark, withdrawn and without joy.

Terror: I used the phrase ancient people - at the beginnings of time the inhabitants thought the sun was gone forever, and they would live in darkness - thus Spring Solstice, when they rejoiced
and celebrated the return of the sun and new life

I appreciate your remarks very much. They are offered sincerely and without rancor.
[8] Niphredil 31-Dec-05/4:24 AM Reply
I thought the last stanza was excellent :-) and the poem as a whole is great.

a little criticism: I don't care for the stanza before last. It adds no additional feeling or tone to the poem, changes its descriptive flow, and I feel it could easily be dropped altogether.

I enjoy reading your work, Sister; keep writing!
[8] zodiac 2-Jan-06/7:58 AM Reply
Hm, I like your more modern-voiced poems a little better. But kudos for the title and Richard III reference.

I'm with Dovina: the transition from winter to full summer needs more transitioning. Yes, it's jarring and juxtaposed. No, I don't think that helps the poem.

Otherwise, good. I'm glad you stuck around after all.
[1] Stephen Robins 10-Jan-06/9:10 AM Reply
Like swallowing a gigantic glass of swamped bed linen.
[9] pollywolly 15-Jan-06/11:48 AM Reply
i like this piece alot. very accurate descriptions and quite animated. i would love to see you write a piece from a different angle e.g how wonderful winter can be. well done
[8] god'swife 21-Jan-06/9:49 PM Reply
Things I Like About This Poem:

Terrific assonance and alliterations.

'Between the dawn and darkening
there are so few hours of living.'
That's a kick ass line.

'Beds are singing'

Personally, each winter I wish for summer afternoons, and each summer I look forward to a cold winter's night. The "grass is always greener", that's me.


Things I'm Not Crazy About In This Poem:

Winter's death is Spring, isn't it?

Winter's chilled and stark bearing has fingers. I cannot picture this. I can picture death or winter having fingers, but not either's mien having fingers.

Death is used twice within four lines. At first the subject is death and then the subject becomes earth's death. The inconsistency is distracting me.

Ancient man. Too vague, too broad. I know there's a better way to say this. How is beyond me(of course, it's always easier said than done). This poem has an erudite mien; 'ancient man' looks lost. Like it was looking for an elementary school textbook and somehow walked into this poem.

If the bed is singing I don't think the covers should be humming. How do you feel about the bed singing of warmth etc...? Or the bed could be singing songs of..., lullabies of..., or hymns to warmth and desperate escape. Maybe it would be best to leave the covers out of it.

The two sentences in the penultimate stanza seem like questions, yet there are no question marks. Am I reading it wrong?

That whole thing about winter not segueing into summer might be solved if you removed 'Then' from the beginning of the stanza.

Oh, I'm also very fond of 'one stray thread of sun'. Thread is a perfect metaphor; thin, elusive, and it echos the notion of a thread of hope.





[n/a] deleted user 27-Feb-06/11:13 AM Reply
im leaving you a comment because i noticed that you recognized how harsh the people on this site can be. i,too, was wondering how that can be productive in anyway? i just wanted to tell you that i appreciate it...for the people who get that type of criticism