poemranker ::believing by whispern_smoke_wisp

DetailsThe poem, its numbers, and the conversation.

Free verse № 123425

believing

Member since 2005 · Posted 14 Apr 2005 · 6 comments

If all it takes for fairies to be real, is you and I saying aloud that we believe in fairies. Then perhaps, the same method will work on God. Please, all of you, say it loudly with me. Let's all agree to belive in some sort of supreme power. Then perhaps we could give peace a chance.

Rate it

0 is the worst, 10 the best. Pick a number, add a comment if you like, then send it. Keys: 0–9 pick, Enter sends.

mean 4.83 weighted 4.96 rank 8723 views 282 View voting details →

6 votes so far. Yours would make 7.6 votes so far

6 comments

[6] Dovina 14-Apr-05/4:04 PM Reply
Why do you expect that a god we all decide to believe in will bring peace? How many of the others have brought peace?
[5] thepinkbunnyofdoom 15-Apr-05/9:56 AM Reply
Peter Pan Logic only works for children. -5-
[7] zodiac 15-Apr-05/11:04 PM Reply
You're probably wondering why you really got such low votes on this one. I'd say it's because you start with a bad assumption ("If all it takes for fairies to be real...") that no one really believes anyway, and then apply it in a kind of backwards way to God (since the fairies bit you copped from Peter Pan was CREATED TO BE a metaphor for childlike beliefs in general, especially belief in God), then you just kind of jump to the bumper-sticker bit at the end. Besides that one, sort of faulty, idea, there's nothing really to make this poetry, no originality of expression or imagery.

Please don't get me wrong. I like you and want to see you stick around and improve. Don't be offended.
[7] zodiac 15-Apr-05/11:05 PM Reply
And no offense intended - really - but it seems like instead of posting a half-dozen mediocre poems at the same time, you could use your two-day limit to REALLY work on ONE of them, maybe the best one, and make it something more than mediocre.
[4] Christof 16-Apr-05/5:07 AM Reply
This is the most egregiously simple-minded philosophy I have ever read in my whole life. Apart from the grafitti on the toilet wall that says 'I didn't write this'. But that's beside the point. The point is that as soon as we all agreed to believe in this supreme power, we'd all then start to argue about what it looked like, what sex it was, what it actually did... adn then, hey presto! We have the last 6000 years of history ALL OVER AGAIN. I think I'll pass on that thanks. And at the same time, I'll pass on this poem, which isn't so much a poem as a mis-spelled, unrhythmical and ultimately whimsical bit of cracker-barrel wiseacreliness. Listen to Zodiac.
[n/a] INTRANSIT 16-Apr-05/3:41 PM Reply
(sees the hitchhiker and goes for the next gear up.)