poemranker ::Rosalía de Castro: When I was born by Sasha

DetailsThe poem, its numbers, and the conversation.

Other № 105986

Rosalía de Castro: When I was born

Member since 2004 · Posted 21 Jun 2004 · Edited 4 Sep 2004 · 11 comments

From the Galician "Nasín cand' as prantas nasen" I was born with plants and blossoms In the month when gardens grew, In a dawn so very gentle In a dawn of April dew. That’s the reason why I’m Rosa With a grin gone red with rue, Bristling thorns for everybody (Never, though, a thorn for you) Since I fell in love (a thankless Thing I did) life’s gone askew And I let it go, believing You my life and glory too. Why then this complaining Mauro? Why the rage? You know it’s true- If my dying made you happy, Happily I’d die for you. Still you stab me with a dagger Spiked with curses. Not a clue What it was you really wanted, Crazy deeds you made me do! All I had to give I gave you In my hungering for you. Now it is my heart I send you With its one unlocking key. I’ve got nothing left to give you, You’ve no more to ask of me.

Rate it

0 is the worst, 10 the best. Pick a number, add a comment if you like, then send it. Keys: 0–9 pick, Enter sends.

mean 8.00 weighted 5.81 rank 1673 views 342 View voting details →

6 votes so far. Yours would make 7.6 votes so far

11 comments

[9] titan69 21-Jun-04/1:47 PM Reply
I just dont know where you get these poems from you must have a great mind!!
[10] Shardik 21-Jun-04/2:36 PM Reply
Come spawn with me...
[10] Shuushin 21-Jun-04/6:00 PM Reply
what you think about using "spake" instead of "spoke"?

I think "daggar" s/b "dagger" unless you a punning a character (it could happen!)


nice one.
[n/a] Sasha › Shuushin 21-Jun-04/6:12 PM Reply
Daggar's a typo. Damn votes will erase if I change it tho.

Using spake for spoke would be completely inappropriate since this poem is somewhat more colloquial than that (at least it's meant to be.) Rosalía de Castro was the first poet in centuries to write in her native Galician, (which is not unlike medieval portuguese) rather than Spanish. Thus her poetry, like Sappho's, is filled with colloquialisms mixed in with slight (and I do mean slight) archaisms. So spake for spoke would be completely out of place in a translation of DeCastro
[10] Shuushin › Sasha 21-Jun-04/6:25 PM Reply
oh, okay. Makes sense - I was just going for the sound of it - but really, it's fine as is.
[10] Shuushin › Sasha 21-Jun-04/6:29 PM Reply
Btw, I think you would enjoy the book called "Baudolino" by Umberto Eco. I'm 2/3rds through it; very good. He has a couple other non-fiction things on semiotics that would be right up your alley.
[n/a] Sasha › Shuushin 21-Jun-04/7:33 PM Reply
I've read his Serendipity
[10] Shuushin › Sasha 21-Jun-04/7:56 PM Reply
Not read that one - any good?
[n/a] Sasha › Shuushin 21-Jun-04/8:32 PM Reply
very. lots of interesting observations on the origin and purpose of language
[10] god'swife 28-Jun-04/11:07 AM Reply
You're translations astound me. This reads beautifully. It makes me feel...good.
[10] sliver 4-Sep-04/8:06 AM Reply
Hey Sasha, long time. I really enjoyed this one, Brings memories to mind that almost make me cry. Just what I needed after last night. Thanks.