poemranker ::The Left Book Club by Nicholas Jones

DetailsThe poem, its numbers, and the conversation.

Free verse № 9027

The Left Book Club

Member since 2002 · Posted 15 Aug 2002 · 6 comments

Christ! The whole thing was a fuck-up, really, All it would have taken was a decent bit of bayonet-waving, Lob a few mortars into the city and that, as they say, Would have been that. But, I forgot, we had to make sure Of our ideological purity first. That is, We were less concerned with winning Than with ensuring that the struggle Had the correct dialectical properties. We debated Hegelian metaphysics in trenches And quoted Marx in the latrines; Our understanding of economic determinism Was the best in the free world. We believed in our aims, we fought hard, And yet, somehow, somewhere, we failed Both ourselves and our people. And the biggest problem is That we were right all along. One day, the leader of our party came to see us, A rare privilege indeed, and we asked him If it was still official policy To shoot any fascist that we saw. He looked hard at us, stroked his Stalinist moustache, and said: "From now on lads, Shoot any man who is not a socialist, It is the only thing That those bastards will understand."

Rate it

0 is the worst, 10 the best. Pick a number, add a comment if you like, then send it. Keys: 0–9 pick, Enter sends.

mean 7.33 weighted 6.17 rank 1024 views 186 View voting details →

9 votes so far. Yours would make 10.9 votes so far

6 comments

[5] poetandknowit 15-Aug-02/7:52 AM Reply
Where is Gollancz when you need him? I wonder whom he would nab today to write the LBC mantra? Are there any good propagandists anymore? Anywho, this works well revealing the LBC from the grunt level revealing the dogmatic good intentions (or deceptive intentions if you consider the poems undertones to violence) along with many in the group's extreme naivete. Interesting subject matter, but I do not like the fuck-up in the first line. It seems out of place? And some of the lines trip in the prose.
[n/a] Nicholas Jones 19-Aug-02/3:07 AM Reply
To be honest, the title is a bit of a red herring. The poem's really meant to be about the Spanish civil war (or at least the International Brigade), but could refer to any revolutionary group.
[9] Christof 23-Sep-02/2:01 AM Reply
George Orwell would have been proud of this. Very good indeed.
[9] god'swife 25-Sep-02/7:16 AM Reply
Please write a short story.
[10] Bachus 15-Jan-03/11:39 PM Reply
<Bachus starts the tape deck>
Nick, would it be alright if i played radio head the bends in the back ground? thanks...
so nick are you a communist?
Alot of great actors came out of wales like richard burton, and i think peter o'toole is that accurate?, and what do you think about their work?
especially o'toole in dr. strangelove? 10.
[10] zodiac 1-Mar-04/9:20 AM Reply
Fabulous.