Replying to a comment on:

Come off with me Carly back into the city (Lyric) by zodiac

- "It's a game," she said. "A what?" "A game - next time we go under a yellow light, touch something metal - like, I don't know, the roof - and say 'Great sex'. And you'll have great sex." "With you?" I said. "Don't be silly." Come off with me Carly Back into the city. We might Drive the empty streets 'til early, Ride back under yellow stoplights, So the summer comes undone. For this wild night I've come unsettled: Come on out! The night is pearly, Wind is blowing white pear petals Across the lawn; and if I'm steady We can un-touch parts of metal Under every yellow stoplight – Un-exist a month of midnights So you won't be dead already – If you'll come back with me Carly To the city once again – All this I pray. The wind, it eddies In a field of yellow nettles By the churchyard that is Carly's, And the church with creeping charlie Rustles in the dark. And then I head on back into the city, Tired and thinking she'd have surely Died another way as early If it wasn't that. And Carly Sits beside me, keeps me fellow, Making all the stoplights yellow While the sky turns flat with gray light - It's the coming, I think, of daylight - And beside me still, a pretty Girl reminds me to be steady, Tells me sentiment is shitty: Touch the roof – and hurly-burly Over the city bursts the sun.

andrewjthomas 28-Jan-04/2:57 PM
i agree that a poem should not be so obtuse that you can't figure out what it's trying to say
however, i also think a good piece doesn't need an explanatory note, that everything you need to get is in the poem itself
however, even with everything in the poem, it shouldn't be completely spelled out for the reader, no hand holding
i just find it more rewarding as a reader if i discover the meaning rather than being told the meaning
of course, this is just my opinion, and when make something as subjective as an opinion about something as equally subjective in definition as poetry, it's bound to be wrong to more than a few people
and i certainly don't claim to be any expert
sorry if i'm being too critical here, you can feel free to tell me to shut up whenever




Track and Plan your submissions ; Read some Comics ; Get Paid for your Poetry
PoemRanker Copyright © 2001 - 2024 - kaolin fire - All Rights Reserved
All poems Copyright © their respective authors
An internet tradition since June 9, 2001