Poemranker [Replying] Thu Nov 21 11:26:05 PST 2024

Replying to a comment on:

I sit here alone deep in thought What will my future bring me? It's so uncertain, and distrought There's million things that scare me. There's dreams not met, there's hopelessness, And feelings of despair For each time I thread on this path I'm scared and run away. Yes, this is life as we see it Its common where we live To turn around, and with a bound to gallop out of reach. But, when i met my Saviour, He changed my life around, He held me with his loving arms, And carried me right on. And now I live with courage, I do not fear the night For by the name of Jesus I see the light. I see the light that guides me I see the light that shines Inside me, growing brighter As with love in me he smiles. He gives me hope to dream on He gives me hope to grow And with each and every passing day I see him more and more. I am not scared or worried My spirit not forlorn There's radiant plans for me I know Because I love him so.

zodiac

30-Dec-05/6:12 AM

To answer Dovina's earlier question:
Imagine a universe without intelligent beings. Now suppose that in this universe there's a plum

O

- And another plum

O

Of course, they're not called 'plums', since there's no one there to call them anything. But I think we can agree that for all practical purposes the plums are there and pretty much the same as they are here.* Are you with me? In English, you'd say, 'There are two plums'. 'Two' is only a description of plums, specifically a description of quantity. We could just as easily say 'There are purple plums' or 'There are round plums'. In a universe with no intelligent beings, the descriptions 'two', 'purple' and 'round' wouldn't exist, of course - no language would. But the nature of the plums, the quantity, color, and shape, wouldn't be any different there. You see?

You can also just as easily (and correctly) say 'One plum and one plum means there are two plums', or 'One plum PLUS one plum means two plums'. That's still just description, right? Mathematicians abbreviate those sentence into '1 + 1 = 2'. They all mean the same thing. They're all only language.

I can even do more complicated descriptions. Suppose in our hypothetical universe I have three valleys, each of which have three plums - or,

\ O O O /\ O O O /\ O O O /

In English, I can say 'There are nine plums', or 'Three valleys with three plums in each of them means there are nine plums altogether', or 'Three groups of three plums means nine plums', or '3 x 3 = 9'. All of those statements are essentially equivalent. They're just our language for describing plums. They don't change the nature of the plums.

WHAT I THINK YOU'RE SAYING: One characteristic of intelligent beings that wouldn't exist in an unintelligent (or God-oriented) universe is our tendency to arbitrarily group discrete, unique objects, to say 'There are two PLUMS' instead of, say, 'There is one round purplish thing and one not-so-round reddish-yellow thing'. You'd think that in, um, Heaven, one could only say 'One round purplish thing and one not-round red-yellow thing means only one round purplish thing and one not-round red-yellow thing.' Everything's unique individualness in the eyes of God means no two things can be grouped into 'plums', ergo no numbers and maths.

Bollocks, I say. I can do math descriptions at any level. For instance, 'How many things with color are there? Two.' Or, 'How many different shapes are there? Two.' Or simply, 'How many things are there? Two.'

Track and Plan your submissions ; Read some Comics ; Get Paid for your Poetry

An internet tradition since June 9, 2001