Poemranker [Replying] Thu Nov 21 20:18:51 PST 2024

Replying to a comment on:

The brook will not freeze over tonight It has rained too hard The water is moving too swiftly Give me your hand I will show you The shallow parts Where the rocks poke out of the water Where it is safe to wade We can cross together One step at a time And dry out our socks By the fire As we watch the water die down When our breath becomes smoke The embers will glow And together we will fade

zodiac

7-Feb-04/8:09 AM

You might consider another word for 'brook', since (here, at least) you can cross a brook in something like two steps. It makes the 'one step at a time' part a sound little overwrought.

Ditto for the shallow parts where rocks poke out of the water. If there are rocks poking out then why are they 'wading'? They could just step on the rocks that are poking out. It being a brook, they wouldn't need more than two rocks, maybe.

And while I'm at it, it's not exactly clear why they're risking freezing water to cross this brook anyway. It's not really a casual thing to cross a near-freezing river. You might add a one-line explanation: "Coming back to camp," or some such.

On the whole, the writing is good. You need to punctuate, and in lines like the rocks that 'poke' out of the water, you might consider better more poetic words. Write back if you can't think of any. Tchuss.

Track and Plan your submissions ; Read some Comics ; Get Paid for your Poetry

An internet tradition since June 9, 2001